1. Captivated, 2011 [Maranatha]
2. Captivated (Deluxe Edition), 2011 [Maranatha]
3. Captivated (Deluxe Edition), 2011 [Maranatha]
4. A Dream To Believe In, Volume 2, 2008 [Word]
5. Sharecropper's Seed, Volume 1, 2007 [Word]
6. Redeemer: The Best of Nicole C. Mullen, 2006 [Word]]
7. Everyday People, 2004 [Word]
8. Live From Cincinnati: Bringin' It Home, 2003 [Word]
9. Christmas in Black and White, 2002 [Word]
10. Talk About It, 2001 [Word]
11. Following His Hand: A Ten Year Journey, 2001 [Syntax/KMG]
12. Nicole C. Mullen, 2000 [Word]
13. Wish Me Love, 1992 [Frontline] (as Nicole)
14. Don't Let Me Go, 1991 [Frontline] (as Nicole)

Compilation Contributions

1. Top 25 Gospel Songs 2012 Edition, 2012 .... "My Tribute/Redeemer" [Maranatha]
2. Word: Six Decades Of Hits, 2011 .... "Redeemer" [Word]
3. Artists In Adoration: 15 Worship Songs from your favorite Christian Artists, 2011 .... "Redeemer" [Word]
4. Open the Eyes of My Heart: Platinum Edition, 2010 .... "Redeemer" [INO]
5. WOW Gospel Christmas, 2007 .... "Lamb of God" [EMI Gospel]
6. The Nativity Story: Sacred Songs, 2006 .... "Angels We Have Heard on High" (from Christmas In Black And White) [Word]
7. Left Behind: World at War Soundtrack, 2006 .... "Call on Jesus," "Come Unto Me," [Word]
8. Wow Gospel 2006, 2006 .... "Without You" [Word]
9. Absolute Modern Worship 2, 2006 .... "Call on Jesus" [Word]
10. End of the Spear Soundtrack, 2006 .... "Always Love You"
11. Every Young Woman's Battle, 2005 .... "The Ring" [Fervent]
12. Absolute Smash Hits For Kids, 2005 .... "Redeemer" [Fervent/Curb/Warner Bros]
13. Worship, 2005 .... "Redeemer" [Marnatha]
14. WOW #1's, 2005 .... "Redeemer" [Word]
15. All Star Gospel Hits: Christmas, 2004 .... "Lamb of God" [Word]
16. WOW Hits 2005, 2004 .... "Everyday People" (from Everyday People) [Sparrow]
17. Faith, Hope, and Love, 2004 ...."Redeemer" [Time Life]
18. One - Pop Hits: Christian Music's #1 Songs, 2003 .... "Show Me" [Madacy]
19. Dove Hits 2003, 2003 .... "Come Unto Me" [Reunion]
20. Our Great God: Songs of the Redeeming Cross, 2003 .... "Redeemer" [Vital Communications]
21. 16 Great Contemporary Christian Classics Vol 2, 2003 .... "Call on Jesus" [Daywind]
22. Pop Hits: Christian Music's #1 Songs, 2003 .... "Show Me" [Madacy]
23. WOW Worship (Yellow), 2003 .... "Redeemer" [Provident]
24. WOW Christmas Red, 2002 .... "O Come, O Come Emmanuel" [Sparrow]
25. WOW Hits 2003, 2002 .... "Talk About It" [Word]
26. Dove Hits 2002, 2002 .... "Call On Jesus" [Word]
27. 16 Great Praise and Worship Classics, 2001 .... "Redeemer" [Daywind]
28. Women of Gospel, 2001 ...."On My Knees" [Word]
29. Mix This: Extreme Music, 2001 ...."Witness" [Word]
30. WOW Hits 2002, 2001 .... "Witness" [Sparrow]
31. WOW Hits 2001, 2000 .... "Redeemer" [Sparrow]
32. Frontline Records - Vol. 8, 1993 ...."Miracles," "Special Wish Me Love Radio Spot" [Frontline] (as Nicole)