A quick skimming of the films I've seen and reviewed here at JFH will reveal an obvious fact that I don't see many "horror" films.
While most movies that fit the genre have become increasingly sadistic and graphic in nature, once in a great while, films like The Mummy, The
Sixth Sense, and now I Am Legend are given a more mainstream market appeal. While the latter, which is also the subject
of this review, is just as much a sci-fi story as it is horror (if not more so), it offers plenty of creepy moments not for the faint
Comparing I Am Legend to a film like 1999's reboot of The Mummy franchise (which sees a third installment
dropping in August of next year), isn't too far of a stretch, but merely because of the kinds of mythical monsters that become
the focal point of the horror elements for I Am Legend. The 1950's novel by the same title, written by Richard Matheson,
proposes the idea of the world being inhabited by a race of vampires after a bacteria spreads infecting all humans - except for one.
That lone uninfected human then carries on the rest of his days as someone who hunts and kills the vampires and anyone carrying
the virus. The 2007 film version, however, differs in the sense that the lone man, Robert Neville, is merely trying to survive his
days as he searches for a cure for those infected and holds out hope for other survivors existing somewhere. It's this idea that
causes the film to veer off course from the book, ultimately giving this theatrical telling a new ending from what the book
offered as well.
This story obviously has no similarities whatsoever to The Mummy, but while that film and its first successor in 2001 both
offered flawed CGI effects when it came to its monsters, I Am Legend suffers from similar missteps. For example, the vampires shown
in I Am Legend are entirely CGI and often look as such. It's only when we first see them in the dark that they look somewhat
tangible. However, as soon as they step into the light, it's exaggerated and cartoony, lower-jaw-extending Imhotep all over again.
While it's not bad enough
to exactly ruin the film, it simply begs for higher quality and more believable effects, and will undoubtedly be something
some viewers will have a hard time looking past. On the other hand, if it had been more realistic - or if regular
actors were used with horrific makeup - the film would have most likely leaned more heavily on the horrific side.
Instead, I Am Legend never really ventures beyond a creepy feel - something horror fans will be bored to tears about,
but it's something this particular reviewer has no problem with.
What's interesting to note is that I Am Legend is more about the psychological elements of a human being stuck in isolation
than anything else. Most of the film is spent following Neville through his daily routines, getting to know what his life is like living
all by himself without any companionship aside from a dog named Sam. Surprisingly enough, Will Smith is a wonderful choice for Neville, giving
the character plenty of depth as he struggles with the solitude as well as the horrors of living in a city with a race of mutated humans that want him
dead. Smith gets a few scenes to really shine, making I Am Legend considerably different than any other major blockbuster film
he's done in the past. While there is action to behold, director Francis Lawrence allows the drama to take over much of the time,
giving thematic weight to the film. Most of the movie is without any kind of musical accompaniment, making the realism all the more
real -- making Neville's loneliness seem all the more serious.
I was also surprised to find a strong spiritual message in I Am Legend. I doubt Matheson's original story had this
intention (although I don't know for certain having never read the book), but it gives a deeper feel to the story. The Tom Hanks
starrer Cast Away, which involved his character spending years completely alone after being stranded on an island, seemed almost
pointless and empty without having any kind of spiritual element. Not once was the idea explored even in part. However, in I Am Legend,
the subject of God surfaces several times - from a flashback scene that shows Neville's wife praying for the Lord to watch over him - to
a character insisting God guided them because He has a plan for them. It added a dimension to the sci-fi story that otherwise would
not have been there and therefore made I Am Legend out to be more than what you think you may get at face value.
The movie's biggest problem is the subpar CGI work for the creatures, but there's little else to complain about besides this
when it comes to story or execution.
The special effects used to make New York look desolate and uninhabited in 2012 is breathtaking and fantastic. Never did these effects
look cheesy or fake. The set pieces for I Am Legend are one of its strongest points next to Smith's acting presence.
Will's interactions with his dog - who indeed steals most of the scenes she's in - make for some of the film's most memorable moments.
In fact, what's most memorable about I Am Legend will be the acting and sets - not necessarily the mutated creatures that
are cause for the film's action scenes and climactic encounter.
The content is surprisingly tame for what you might expect with this premise and Smith's position in the lead. Language is sparse
at best with a handful of obscenities. Ironically, in a flashback, Neville's wife uses a brief exclamation of blasphemy before later
praying over her husband. It seemed a bit contradictory in behavior, especially when it was the only real standout use of it in the film.
While it's possible some characters muttered a few additional swear words under their breath when things heated up a bit, profanity was
seldom used throughout the course of the movie. Some scenes get very violent, albeit non-graphically, which make it anything but a family
film. Blood and terror isn't a focal point and the camera pulls away from some of the more intense moments. Finally, sexual content is barely
an issue, but while in a video rental store, we do see two shelves of adult films which have racy covers, but the camera doesn't linger
on them and they're mostly out of focus as well.
I Am Legend is a well-constructed and weighty sci-fi thriller with some horror thrown in for good measure. Too scary and creepy to not be labeled
horror, but not terrifying enough to satisfy fans of the genre, I Am Legend is more a film for adults than youngsters.
A little language here and there, coupled with some jump scenes and eerie moments, as well as plenty of action violence, make this
a tough one to recommend. The film, however, does offer a spiritual message - enough to discuss afterwards even - but I Am Legend is still
a dark and even emotional cinematic experience regardless.
- John DiBiase, (reviewed: 12/13/07)
Parental Guide: Brief Summary of Content
We see an non-explicit nude sketch of a woman's back hanging on the wall in an apartment; Robert goes to the video store
and we see the non-explicit covers of two different shelves of adult movies. They're out-of-focus, racy covers but don't show any specific nudity;
A female infected vampire is shown on a medical table and its clothing is very skimpy and worn out, but no nudity is seen
1 "s" word (plus 1 possible), 4 "h*ll," 3 "d*mn," 1 "J*sus," 2 "Oh my G-d," 1 "G-d"
After Robert chases Sam into a dark building, he finds blood splattered on a wall which leads up steps where we see the non-bloody
dead head of a deer; A couple times we see the surface of some of the infected's skin begin to burn in the sun;
In a flashback, we see Robert's car either hit an infected or be attacked by one and just briefly and suddenly see a face press up
against his car's window with blood splattering on the window; In a flashback, it looks like a sickly woman might be crying a tear drop of blood;
We see some blood drip off the top of Robert's head as he hangs upside down. When he cuts himself down, he accidentally stabs himself
in the leg with the knife he uses and the blade breaks off, sticking out of his leg (not bloody). We then however see a closeup of
the knife wound cleaned up and maybe sewn (it was difficult to tell), but it's not especially graphic or gory;
We see an animal with blood on its body and neck; We see a creature beginning to change
to a vampiric state after being bitten and we see its eye begin to get red and perhaps bloody with its gums looking diseased;
Robert has blood on his shirt, face and hands; Robert has blood on his neck after being attacked; Many times we see the vampires/infected
strewn about after being run over or blown up, but nothing is particularly graphic or gory; The emaciated, sore-covered look of
the infected is creepy and is likely to unsettle some viewers.
(POSSIBLE SPOILER ALERT!)
New York City is desolate after humans are infected and become vampiric monsters that eat and kill uninfected humans. Several
times we see the creatures attack people and bite them and chase after them and such; Robert shoots up a mannequin in anger of
thinking at one point it was alive and then shoots in the air at surrounding buildings; Robert traps an infected by roping it and
then knocks it out while it's under a blanket; A vampire tied to a table suddenly lunges at Robert; We see a cage full of lab
rats that have been tested on - most look vicious while some have died; Vampires attack Neville and fall out a window on the ground
and die in the sunlight; Some vampire dogs attack Sam and Neville; Robert strangles a vampire dog to death (all seen from the view
of his face, not the actual action); In a flashback, we see people leap onto a helicopter as it's taking off and this causes it
to loose control and crash into another helicopter (the scene cuts right before impact); Neville runs a horde of infected over with his car, including pinning them up against a pole, etc;
Neville violently throws a plate against a wall and two other characters grab a gun and knife, but nothing happens;
A mob of vampires attack Neville's location and he blows them up. We see the bodies strewn about. One then attacks him and bites his
neck and drags him around. He shoots them and another; Another mob attacks Robert. An explosion presumably kills more vampires.
** Disclaimer: All reviews are based solely on the opinions of the reviewer. Most
reviews are rated on how the reviewer enjoyed the film overall, not on content. However, if the content
really affects the reviewer's opinion of the film, it will definitely affect the reviewer's rating.