It's no surprise that after the success of 2004's Disney adventure film National Treasure, that a sequel would
follow three years later. The original, although being rough around the edges enough to hint that it may have been edited to PG
status from a light PG-13, was family-friendly and well-written enough to win mass appeal. It was one of the more exciting ways
to tell about history, intertwining historical facts about our nation with fiction and a treasure hunting element. Dropping
Nicolas Cage into the leading role gave the film a name and enough talent to carry the movie that relied heavily on puzzle-solving
and North America-trotting to keep things fun and exciting. The end result definitely made the idea of a sequel enticing indeed.
The trailers that surfaced in early 2007 for National Treasure: Book Of Secrets, the first follow-up
to the original, definitely promised more of what fans of loved about the first one. But with nearly every sequel, there are things
within the second installment's storyline that may change your experience of the original beyond what you've come to believe or
imagine how the characters ended up after the first story's conclusion. I'm going to divulge
some of these changes and story developments here, and while they don't spoil the movie, they are plot facts that you wouldn't learn
about just from watching the trailer or reading a brief synopsis. First of all, when we last saw our heroes in National Treasure,
Abigail and Ben had fallen for each other and were on the road to happiness. However, that's not how things apparently turn out.
When Book Of Secrets begins, we learn that not only did Abigail NOT join the Gates family as Ben's wife, but she kicked him
out of her house that they were living in together and was starting to see someone else. Usually this would be some thin plot
excuse to write a main character out of a sequel who may just be played by someone who had chosen not to reprise their role.
However, Diane Kruger does return as Abigail Chase and it all just feels like an unnecessary attempt to work in some character
conflict that may not otherwise exist. In a way, it tarnishes our sweet little idealistic ending from the previous film and makes
their efforts in the sequel feel a bit like a retread of them falling in love like the first Treasure. Another strange
plot element is the use of Oscar-winning actress Helen Mirren as Ben's mother and, incidentally, his father's (played by Jon Voight) ex-wife.
Because there was no mention of Mrs. Gates in the previous film, it just seems a little too convenient to write in Ben's mom along with
even more relational conflict as they just naturally become forced to spend time together. The character dynamic between
the two seems forced and even disposable, and while it's fun at times to have Voight in the picture again, it's a bit corny when
the whole thing inevitably turns into one big family affair.
The first film wasn't without its extreme stretches of imagination and National Treasure: Book Of Secrets seems to
only stretch that further. There are some near eye-rolling moments, but the passion of Cage's performance as Benjamin and
the fun of seeing Abigail and Riley at his side on another treasure chase makes the film worthwhile for anyone who enjoyed the first
installment. With Sean Bean out of the picture as the villain in the previous Treasure film, another reliable actor, Ed Harris, steps in
as our anti-hero. Harris offers a strong, intimidating presence, but as the story progresses, falls prey to some weak lines
in the script and some of your usual villain cliches. Still, Harris pulls it off more successfully than most others in his
shoes may have, helping this sequel from becoming something as horrid as another Tomb Raider episode. The patriotism and sincerity
of National Treasure: Book Of Secrets is honorable, which also helps the enjoyability factor, but it isn't enough to make
up for the liberties taken in the reality department. But even at its silliest, Book Of Secrets is still plenty entertaining
and fun. The puzzles are imaginative and exciting, and its often an infectious feeling to watch the characters' wonder as they
uncover well-crafted clue after well-crafted clue.
The content is actually slightly more mild than the first film. Language is limited to a single "My G-d" as an exclamation, while most
of the violence is nonlethal and not in any way graphic. But keep in mind that there is still plenty of action within, including a
sort of "lite" version of the kind of car chase you might find in a Bourne film, and some physical punches thrown and such.
Also, a climactic sequence does end in the death of a character, and it may be a bit dramatic/harrowing for some younger viewers (as well
as some other exciting, perilous moments).
Finally, there is a mild scene of sensuality when Abigail tries to distract a man so Ben can look for something, and she ends up
passionately kissing the man in the process.
While we all could have done without the seemingly random tense family quarrels and related dramatics, National Treasure:
Book Of Secrets still retains enough of what made the first film so fun to keep it interesting and enjoyable. But because there
is a slight, detectable case of "sequelitis" that can sadly almost be expected these days, Book Of Secrets isn't the film
it could have been, and therefore just can't top the first experience three years ago. Still, if you're looking for a little holiday
escapism, you could definitely do a lot worse than the benign entertainment that is National Treasure: Book Of Secrets.
- John DiBiase, (reviewed: 12/20/07)
Parental Guide: Brief Summary of Content
shows some cleavage in an outfit and, to distract a man, mildly seduces him, ending it with a passionate kiss as she tries to distract
him from what Ben is doing across the room. The kiss is sensual, but nothing comes out of it
Vulgarity/Language: 1 "My G-d"
Alcohol/Drugs: Emily comments twice
about tequila being what brought her and Patrick together originally.
Violence: We see
a man shoot President Lincoln (off screen); we see another man shoot a man who we then watch die (not bloody); a car chase
results in streets and buildings damaged; people are shot at; a man's house is broken into and he's knocked unconscious; a man
punches a few other people; a person holds another with a knife to their throat (no one is harmed); a person drowns to death
** Disclaimer: All reviews are based solely on the opinions of the reviewer. Most
reviews are rated on how the reviewer enjoyed the film overall, not on content. However, if the content
really affects the reviewer's opinion of the film, it will definitely affect the reviewer's rating.