It was six years ago when VeggieTales got their first chance at the silver screen. Jonah: A VeggieTales Movie
was a modest success at best, but an achievement for Christian cinema. While a follow-up film was originally planned to
be centered around a story about how Bob and Larry first met, the news of a second feature-length film died down when
Big Idea, Inc. went bankrupt. Reportedly, co-creator and writer Phil Vischer had come up with the idea for
the next film, The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything, even before Disney found success with the 2003 film,
Pirates Of The Caribbean, but his story wouldn't see the light of day until two more sequels from the Disney franchise
would be released.
The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything - A VeggieTales Movie is a much different VeggieTales experience than before.
We not only don't meet the characters of Bob and Larry - or any of the shows cast of characters - as themselves, but the story
begins and ends with each Veggie starring as a different character for the story (and don't expect to see Jr. Asparagus,
Laura The Carrot, or anything more than a couple of frames of Bob The Tomato). And this time, it's not at all a Biblical
storytelling like Jonah was. The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything - A VeggieTales Movie relies wholly on its story
to deliver a message that's relevant, yet subtle in its Christian thematics.
The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything opens in the 17th century, introduces us to several new characters, and sets up
our plot where a damsel in distress needs a couple of heroes to save her and her brother. What inevitably happens is, instead of your expected
stereotypical heroes, the likes of Larry (as Elliot), Pa Grape (as George), and Mr. Lunt (as Sedgewick) show up and must fight
their urge to be lazy and decide to pitch in. What unfolds is a clever little story with enough fun included to keep us entertained
for its duration. In recent years, VeggieTales has found some of its most golden moments in spoofing popular stories -
from Indiana Jones to Lord Of the Rings and The Wizard Of Oz. Surprisingly, there isn't a single reference
in this particular pirates story to Pirates Of The Caribbean, which can be good in the sense that it relies on its own
footing, but in some respects also feels like there are a few missed opportunities. VeggieTales has often succeeded more greatly
when spoofing (or retelling a known Bible story) than when trying to come up with an original story, and some of this is felt
in The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything.
One of the strangest observations I struggle to admit is that there are more than just a couple similarities in the events of
The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything to that of the 1998 sci-fi comedy Galaxy Quest. In the latter, a group of
actors are mistaken by aliens in distress for heroes and must band together to rescue them from an oppressing villain.
In that story, there is a prominent sequence with a rock monster, a race of little creepy creatures that chase one of our
heroes, and a scene where - in a tight spot - the heroes try to convince the story's villain that they're nothing more than
just actors mistaken for something more (and I won't even go into one of the final scenes which also is uncannily similar... but
just replace the fan convention with a dinner theater here).
In The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything, all of those elements can be found, with the race of aliens replaced by the hilariously
disturbing race of vicious little cheese curls. Whether or not these similarities between the two stories is intentional, it's
surprising that a list of such comparisons can even be made between such visibly different films.
Content is obviously mild being that the film is rated G, but parents will want to keep in mind a few instances that
are likely to be pretty intense for their younger ones. The aforementioned cheese curls are ridiculously creepy and the scene
where they're revealed and chase one of the veggies through a dark cave (and show up a couple times throughout the rest of
the film, including the end credits), are possibly a bit unsettling. It's only during the end credit silly song where they're
shown dancing (much like the screeching slugs in Flushed Away) that they seem more harmless. Also, there's some swashbuckling
and a couple appearances by a mechanical sea monster that could scare some little kids, but nothing is ever lethal or grotesque.
As usual, VeggieTales keeps things pretty light even when it seems a bit ominous.
Overall, it's one of the more impressive looking VeggieTales productions, but it still can't hold a candle to such
those by DreamWorks or Pixar. Even though it's clear this film is geared towards youngsters and families - more so than
even the ones from the mentioned film companies - it's tough not to admit that not only has Big Idea done better in the past, but there
have been much, much more impressive and entertaining feature-length animated films for families before (last year's
G-rated Ratatouille even comes to mind). Although there's no blatant Biblical message, the moral of the story
is a bold one about "the King" (an obvious reference to God) choosing the least likely heroes to do his will and get the
job done. In the end, The Pirates Who Don't Do Anything - A VeggieTales Movie remains an encouraging, family-friendly
film with a positive message about being able to achieve great things even when the circumstances seem way out of our qualifications
to handle. While the film could have been stronger (and a bit funnier), the VeggieTales charm is still present
and fans of the series shouldn't be disappointed in their latest theatrical storytelling.
- John DiBiase, (reviewed: 1/11/08)
Parental Guide: Brief Summary of Content
Violence: Some nonlethal swordfighting,
Robert holds a sword to Alexander; Robert's men put a dummy on a boat and sail it into a water mine to show what he hopes to do
to the King, A cannonball ricochets off a rock and hits a boat sail which knocks a man off a boat and causes the ship to crash
into the rocks; A ship fires on a rowboat with cannons; Evil cheese curls chase a veggie around; A chandelier knocks over a character;
Elliot is eaten by a visibly mechanical sea monster. We then see him cut a hole in the neck of it and poke his head out; (and
other minor, nonlethal cartoony violence)
** Disclaimer: All reviews are based solely on the opinions of the reviewer. Most
reviews are rated on how the reviewer enjoyed the film overall, not on content. However, if the content
really affects the reviewer's opinion of the film, it will definitely affect the reviewer's rating.