During World War II, England communicated with the French Resistance and Allied troops in Europe using
the Royal Pigeon Service, using carrier pigeons that went through a rigorous training regimen. This is the story of Valiant, a comically clumsy misfit of a (wood) pigeon who sneaks his way into the Royal Pigeon Service, eager to contribute his efforts to the needs of his country, even though he is vastly unqualified to do so. Immediately given an assignment, Valiant's job turns out to be one of the most important of the war... carrying essential messages from the French to the Allied forces who are about to storm the beaches of Normandy on D-Day.
Where some films may lack in originality, they can excel in creativity. Disney's British animated comedy
Valiant definitely fits this description. Valiant is Ewan McGregor's second outing this
year voicing a lead animated character (first was Rodney in Robots), but is a far different film.
While both Robots and Valiant center on a character set out to follow his dreams against
the odds, Valiant feels like a much more low budget project. Does this mean it's not as good? I wouldn't
jump to say that...
Watching Valiant reminds me of listening to a new band who is nothing really original, but
still has something unique about them that makes it very hard not to like them. The film recycles common plot elements,
like a main character who doesn't share the same heroic passion as the lead and, well, flies the coop when the going gets
tough. Of course, we know they'll return when needed, in that sort of 'Han Solo comes back to save Luke' fashion.
There's the typical underdog who wants to make a difference, the unbeatable villain, the love interest,
and the team of hopeless losers who save the day. It's all hear. And despite it being very familiar,
it works because its packaging is completely new. British messanger pigeons during WWII? You have to love it!
With the outrageous plot comes the outrageous jokes, and there's plenty of them. While most of the gags
are subtle, it's the idea of the story, the mannerisms of the pigeons (seeing Valiant move and twitch like
a real pigeon when reacting to things or listening to someone talk is priceless), and the subtle British humor
that are the real charm of the picture. The inclusion of Monty Python alumnus John Cleese as a POW is the
clincher. And when you're starting to just sit and take in the story and characters, the filmmakers toss
some fantastic random humor into the mix, like the introduction of two French mice (including a pudgy little
demolition-happy one). The scenery in the film is also often dazzling, while some aspects of the animation
seem second-rate at best. For example, some objects actually seemed blocky or pixelated close-up, while
that's something you would almost never see in a big animated production from Pixar or DreamWorks.
The animation lacks the intense detail of those studios as well. Everything sort of has a strangely
polished glow. It created a unique look that sets the film apart from others made in recent years, but it
also seemed like less time was put into the detail of the animation. The quality appears to be a step
backward. But perhaps this is intentional to give the film an older feel because of the era it's
Valiant makes for good family entertainment, but I do wonder if most of the humor will go over
kids' heads. Because it does take place mostly in London, the British accents and lingo can be a tad hard
to decipher at times, and I can bet it would be much harder for the kids to pick up. It seems much more
like something the adults would appreciate more than the kids. But the best word to describe Valiant
is that it's absolutely "cute," and that alone will probably attract the younger audiences.
All in all, I enjoyed Valiant a lot. It may seem painfully familiar at times or contrived
as far as the story goes, but examining the world of pigeons in WWII as brilliantly as they did is what
makes Valiant a winning film.
- John DiBiase, (reviewed: 9/14/05)
Parental Guide: Brief Summary of Content
Sex/Nudity: Bugsy suggestively and jokingly
asks a female nurse if she has anything for him and she shows him a large needle (to which he and others faint);
A French female mouse talks to the boys about a message, which sounds like "massage" when she says it. Bugsy jokingly
says he'd like a fully body massage.
Alcohol/Drugs: Some birds have various
drinks in a bar, including "bug juice."
Blood/Gore: Valiant regurgitates a piece
of paper and we see yellow goo all over it and on the ground.
Violence: Cartoon-style violence
that includes war-related violence. We see a plane crash, falcons chasing the pigeons (in an attempt
to kill them); the bones of
previously imprisoned pigeons; some characters fighting played for laughs, and some for excitement, etc
** Disclaimer: All reviews are based solely on the opinions of the reviewer. Most
reviews are rated on how the reviewer enjoyed the film overall, not on content. However, if the content
really affects the reviewer's opinion of the film, it will definitely affect the reviewer's rating.