With the release of the curiously titled Church Music, the modern worship act David Crowder*Band
offer fans of the genre a unique worship experience that begs to be talked about. While stopping in Pennsylvania for a
spot on their Fall Church Music Tour, we had the pleasure of sitting down with front man David Crowder to discuss the
album at length...
This interview took place on: 11/8/09.
Jesus freak Hideout (John DiBiase): ...Church Music is definitely a different
approach for you guys. A Collision had that bluegrass, country-ish feel at times. Remedy was a little more... "safe."
It was a palette cleanser, yeah. I don't know how much you are following what we're doing, but we're [doing] like a seven
"works" - I can't call them "albums" because the seventh one might be a little weird, but - modeled on the Creation story.
Y'know how the second three days mimicked the first three days with "Let there be light?" Well then by day four,
you've got the sun and the moon... it's a little crazy to think about. So Remedy was sort of the sibling or
cousin, however you want to say it - it was related to Can You Hear Us?, and Church Music's related
to Illuminate. Just in the overarching "we need some sort of structure outline to fit what we're doing
into" and so it sort of gives us a big "meta-thing" we're working under. So yeah, Remedy was reminiscent of
Can You Hear Us? and to me, Church Music and Illuminate are pretty similar in a lot of ways.
So the next one, obviously, is A Collision's brother or sister or cousin. Whatever dubious relation you can
come up with.
JFH (John): Well, it's interesting, because when I popped in Church Music,
I was really expecting kind of just another worship record or a hymns record or something. So what made you choose
such a title for such a direction?
Well, I'm kind of a nerd with language. I love language in the sense that it's fluid. Granted, if you're talking to linguists,
you can argue for hours about what causes definition to occur, whether it's usage or strict defs, but I feel like usage
creates the fluidity of language. The way we use words will shape what they mean in the future. So "church music" -
these are just two little words that immediately create expectation in people. Like if you're coming from a more
progressive setting, you would hear these words and know our music and go, "This is not quite like church music."
Choir robes... organ... A little more reserve would be necessary. And if you're coming from a traditional setting,
you would hear these words and hear our music and go, "Absolutely not! This is NOT church music! This is much too
irreverent." And I think what's amazing about the two words is there's critique for all of us in it. That if we're
thinking about art... if you think of the global church, here's this faith erupting from very different cultures
and people and yet we tend to think of everybody like ourselves. That there's this expectation that others' expression
would look like ours, and so there's this inability to appreciate what's coming from another group of people that
are carrying the same story and verbalizing it in very different ways. And so, to me it's been fun. We've been sitting on
the words for awhile, all knowing we'd come to it in the second cycle of things, because, another little inside deal...
The syllables in the titles - the first round are four syllables and the second round are three syllables, which the
first of the records are more, I think, human or materially. The content matter, what we're talking about, seems more
earthly, and as we're moving forward, it's going to, I think, have a little bit more of a transcendent flair in the
content. That was an aside.
But "church music" - the words - I just liked that the words have a lot of power to shape expectation. And you couldn't
have made this -- you know, being in Christian music -- we couldn't have put out a record like this ten years ago and
called it Church Music. You wouldn't get the, I don't know, satire, irony of it... (John: Sarcasm.)
Yeah. At this point, there's enough of that tongue-in-cheek thing available, which is encouraging, because I think that's
what the church does really poorly. Y'know, when the rest of the world's communicating culturally in irony and satire,
the church doesn't know how to do anything except talk literally. So I think it's a good sign that we could do a record
like this and people kind of "get it."
JFH (John): So what inspired you to do the title track in the style of disco?
Which kind of furthers your point that this record isn't your typical church music...
David: Yeah, that's very true. To use music that's known as one of the more self-indulgent
eras in music, I like the juxtaposition of it. And it's the same with the lyric. So, you've got "church music"
and it's juxtaposed with this selfish, cultural thing that we breathe - I mean individualism is just what
we breathe in and out every day of our lives - yet what we're trying to build is community. Cuz again, all our stuff
is coming from a local church setting, so our intention in building a church is to try to figure out how to foster
community in some sense. And it's just [that] always you're bumping up against individualism. So, to take the most indulgent
era of pop music that we've had in the recent past and put it with this thing that's supposed to tear away the individual
and allow us to speak and be free to point at each other and say "Hey dude, let's call each other to something
grander than what we're living currently," seemed to make sense. And as well, to try to hint that... If you strip the music
from the lyrics, they're really pretty bleak in a sense. "Dance if you're wounded?" I mean, that's bizarre. Usually,
you'd propose something joyous to dance on behalf of, rather than [that]. So all of that was just to point to the space that the church
exists within culturally here in America and help call us to something bigger I guess is the attempt.
JFH (John): So what were your stylistic inspirations for the whole record?
David: Well, here's what we did: I think with each record we've approached
the recording process differently. This time around, knowing we were going to call it Church Music, our
conversation and what we'd been talking about - "If we're going to call it this, then what should it look like, what
should it sound like, what should it be?" - and actually where it wound up was not where we thought it would be in the
beginning. And we're usually working a record ahead, so we were working on this while working on Remedy, so
we were headed out - this was like two Summers ago - on the Passion World Tour, and we thought, "Oh, this will be amazing!
We'll get to go around the globe, be in all these different cultures, we'll check out what is the authentic expression of
all these places different than the United States of America and see what their current progressive worship sounds like
and looks like. Well, what it sounds like and looks like is that America has been incredibly adept at not only exporting goods and
materials (*laughs*), but also our lastest worship hits. Cuz that's all they're playing is like American worship music.
And I was so mad. I couldn't tell you how mad I was. I was like, "You gotta be kidding -- I mean, I'm glad you like our music,
I'm glad you're singing it, but what are you guys writing? What's coming out of your experience?" And so we then re-shifted
and thought, "Well, let's look at the cultures that these churches are existing within. If, say, on a theoretical level,
the Crowder*Band lived in Tokyo in Japan, what would the music of this Crowder*Band sound like, look like, if we were to
try to give an authentic expression or articulation of faith in Tokyo?" And so in each city, we collected a lot of pop music,
so [while we were] there we just bought a bunch of J-Pop, and in Korea, got a bunch of K-Pop, so just went around collecting a bunch of
the music, and started noticing that, especially once we were in Europe, that so many of the producers that are doing
big pop hits now... Well, I should back up - One, noticing that pop has moved in a much more urban direction than
when we started ten years ago. Ten years ago, the modern worship movement, I think, was really just an embrace of
pop music at the time. The church threw its arms back around something that was common among us. Pop music, y'know, we were
influenced [by] whether we were shopping at JC Penny or on the Internet. Doesn't matter, you're bombarded. And it shapes
your sensibilities and what moves you as a human. And at the time was the praise chorus, which was a very innovative
moment for the church. When the praise chorus was able to expand, what it expanded into was basically Britpop, mostly
U2-oriented music. If we could pull off U2, if you could get your guitarist with his dotted eighth note on the delay
pedal, in love with The Edge and these big grand arena melodies, then we were golden. And so it let the praise chorus grow into
something a little more provocative, I guess. So that was ten years ago when this thing happens, and it seems like the
same model keeps getting regurgitated over and over and meanwhile, it's either urban-based stuff that's selling, or I mean,
even Katy Perry - it's all urban-based, the production end, the track that the stuff is sitting on top
of. It's either that or Taylor Swift. *laughs* It's either Lil Wayne or Taylor Swift that's selling.
So it seemed to us that means we need to start with track. Because we feel
like when the church has been most effective, and with church music when there's been this moment of creative explosion
where art has all of a sudden blossomed, it's been when the church has thrown its arms around whatever was common among
us. As music lovers, it can be really easy to hate on pop music, because it is pretty much the lowest common denominator
of things, but as a hymn-writer or a writer of congregational songs, what you're trying to do is put your finger
on the pulse of what's common. So it seems like that's where we needed to look first, is towards pop music. And pop
music was track-related and track-based, so we started with track.
JFH (John): So when it came time to write these songs, did you feel like it
was natural -- like do you really like the songs that you wrote, or...?
David: Oh, well, that's always necessary, obviously. We're pretty good at the editorial side of things,
I think, if something ain't happenin'... And I love pop music, I should say that to begin with,
so naturally, I think what we as a band, our tastes are really broad. It's from Waylon Jennings to Lil Wayne. I'll
give him some cred. *laughs* - and to have that broadness. And all the indie rock stuff, y'know. We're on a college
campus, so college radio... Grizzly Bear is about the best thing that has happened in years. So, you've got all of that
that we have among us as a community, and we're trying to stick it all in one spot so that it feels like, again, an
authentic response to who God is and what He's done. So in a sense, we're creating just from what's inside of us, but it
also seems we view what we're doing in a utilitarian kind of way. What we do is useful to the extent that it provides an ability
for our community to voice things back to God. If it's unsuccessful in that, then it's just self-indulgence. So that's where
our attempt has been.
JFH (John): The thing I like about the record is it's a lot more textured and
daring and "risky" then a lot of worship music can be. It seems a lot of worship music is stuck in a safe plane. The
core of it sounds the same, like you said, kind of a U2 sort of mimic or whatever. Do you feel like overall a lot of worship
music is like that?
David: Well, I don't listen to a lot of worship music, to be honest. Well, that's slightly
disingenuous. Well, no, I can say that. I don't listen to a lot of worship music, but I pay attention to the songs
that get really big. Cuz we want to have a local expression sure, which is what our purpose is is to articulate our unique
experience, but I also want to connect our church to the broader church. Like if there's something happening in the
American church that fits, I want to pull it in so that we're connected to the whole in a sense as well the same globally.
Like we're trying to find what's an expression that's happening [globally]. A good example would be "Mighty To Save."
This is a song that is really ubiquitous. We'd be on the other side of the planet - well, granted, it came from the
other side of the planet, but - We'd be here in America and on the other side of the planet, here's this song that just
takes over. We'd go into all these different spots on this tour and that would just be this big moment. Well, we would do
it in our church to try to connect everybody, and it's just a flop at our church. Because the people that are
there have a lot of issues with church language. There's a lot of baggage that they come with that we're trying to help
them set down. So we would force feed a thing like "Mighty To Save," to help them see and get a picture of what's
happening elsewhere, so I'm saying it's disingenuous in the sense that I haven't listened to a lot of it, but I try
to find things that I can insert into our experience that will help connect us to the bigger thing.
But I don't think what you're hearing - the sort of redundancy of it - isn't necessarily bad. It's like why we get stuck.
It's like why the hymns stayed around for long. Because what it becomes is this way that we as the church respond to God.
And then so our expectation of how we approach God and how a response to God looks like and how we posture ourselves,
it becomes a model we come back to again and again, because we want that same experience, the same thing. But what you'll
have is, eventually, people that come along and [find that] there's some staleness in some places and there are people
that are getting sort of frustrated by the staleness. So how can we keep going forward, y'know? How can we keep throwing
our arms around what's happening currently and I think you have to be in a unique environment to be able to do that.
Because, again, all these people that you're hearing the records come from, are in communities of folks that if they were
doing anything like what we're doing would be useless. Like, you're not giving that authentic expression to your congregation.
JFH (John): Right, that "style" is still reaching people. We're more of the minority.
David: Yes. So you see moments like this where we feel like, "Oh man, there's something ahead of us," and
I think you need people pointing ahead, but not at the sake of communities that are really thriving and don't need anything
other than what we've got currently.
JFH (John): Do you think the church is embracing the new record?
David: Well, I should say that the people who've attached to the music seem to like it for
the most part... unless you just don't like any electronic-oriented stuff. Which, to me, means you don't listen to
stuff that's [current]. Another thing we watch is commercial music. Not just like, "cool, we're going to grab the indie song
and stick it on [our record] to legitimize our company," but like bumper music in and out of football or in and out of
news casts and stuff. Like these people aren't at the edge of things, but they're very conscious of it. They're using sound
and music in a way that shapes psychologically how the experience of the viewer is. And, to me, the church is not
where culture is. Because all of the music that you hear, is not what you hear in worship music - where, rewind ten years ago,
I think we were. I think it was where it was, but in a decade already, we're sort of behind because we found something that
worked. It felt new and fresh. (John: It's comfortable now too.) Yes. But I think if we
continue in the conversation of how do we continue to tell the story of God in a compelling way to people outside of the
church, our art will continue to have to follow the trends of where we are as a larger culture, not just where we are as
a church culture.
JFH (John): Do you have a favorite or most meaningful song on the new record (Church Music)?
David: Um, hmmm... Y'know, I think the "Eastern Hymn" is probably one that I am most attached to.
It seems like it gets to say the most and it has a bridge that has a lot that it proposes in the middle of it, just due to
the political climate, even the stuff that we've been talking about. Just that there's a lot within the church that
is difficult to talk about and the conversations can get heated and passionate very quickly.
JFH (John): Why the song title "Birmingham?"
David: That is a secret. *laughs*
JFH (John): Really? Why is it a secret?
David: Yeah. Well, because we want people to discover. There's a couple of people that get pretty close,
and so we'd like to keep it for discovery. There's a lot of that stuff... We told each other that we'd talk about this record
after we're on to the next one. We'll get to tell everyone. The other thing is, the history of church music is hidden in
the record. Like, the first song is "Phos Hilaron" or "Hail Gladdening Light." It's got several different names, but it's
the first song outside of scripture that's still in use in church today, mostly in Orthodox settings. So we start at the
beginning of the Christian church - obviously after the death and Resurrection of Christ - so that was like first, second
century when that song occurred. There's only one hymn that can be dated prior to that, but it's crazy. It talks about
unbridled cults and... I mean, it's useless! *laughs* So it's probably why it's not used today, so this is the
first one that's still in use. And then by "Eastern Hymn," we have reached the Middle Ages where the Pope has banned the
tri-tone, the dreaded tri-tone - augmented fourth, diminished fifth - and declared it the Devil's interval. And in the
chorus, granted you'd have to know music theory to catch most of the historical content but, the chorus sits on top of
a tri-tone movement in the baseline, and it functions like a movement of four to five, but it's really an inversion
of the five to four. It's a tri-tone. The whole history to where we are and where we, as a band, theorize we are headed
is in the record and we'll eventually just spell it all out. There's a bunch of people on the forums and stuff trying
to figure out everything. We don't want to ruin it till they have a chance. *laughs*
JFH (John): That's super cool. So, "What A Miracle" was originally a rap about Atlanta?
David: How do you know this?!
JFH (John): Um... it's in the 'Song by Song' *laughs* So I don't know who wrote it...
David: Oh, really?! Oh, no! That's hilarious! I think Hogan must have written that. Well, actually we wrote
it, I must not have read that. That's hilarious! Here's what's funny -- it was about Atlanta, but we were in Dallas.
*laughs* We were in the old Reunion Arena where the Mavericks play so we were down in the Mavericks' locker room,
and we were imagining pregame. And I had just had this track going, and before I knew it, Mark and them had proposed this
whole rap about the ATL: guns and drugs, everything. It was all there.
JFH (John): *laughs* Probably wouldn't have fit on the record.
David: No, it didn't. It didn't make sense. *laughs*
JFH (John): That's awesome. Can you talk about the song, "Can I Lie Here" - its imagery and even how you
recorded it? Because the drum sound is awesome.
David: Oh man, yeah, that was a fun one to track. It was a Logic File at first. It was just these big
huge drum reverb things, y'know? Not listenable, but just the idea was there. And so to go after it, we wound up in
my garage, which was quite lively. The sound seemed to last forever in there. So that was a fun one. Just the production
side of things was a blast. But the content - one of the problems we run into writing congregational songs, especially now,
a lot of times in the charismatic movement it seems like romantic language is one of these contentious things among us,
whether it's appropriate or inappropriate. So we could talk for a long bit about that. It's sort of a pun of a song.
What we're really saying is, "Is it possible to be inauthentic in our worship?" And I don't think it's possible. In
the sense that God knows the heart, then all the posturing and the stuff we bring into a moment of corporate worship
is pretty useless when it's the heart that's what's visible. So, to be in the presence of God, is impossible to be
dishonest. And that's what the song's really saying. "Can I lie here in Your arms?" It's "No, I can't."
JFH (John): That's interesting. So the "lie" means to lie...
David: Correct. Rather than the romantic side. But we knew that everyone would have this nice fuzzy,
soft feeling about it.
JFH (John): Now there's a really cool story about how you met Lacey from Flyleaf,
David: Oh! Man, yeah!
JFH (John): Can you talk about that and what lead you to want to cover "All Around Me?"
David: Well, actually, the story is combined, cuz it all sort of happened at once. They're like right
down the street from us in Temple area, which is about thirty minutes from Waco, so they would pop up to services
occasionally, and [I] didn't know who they were but this group of people would occasionally appear and they usually
would take up the front section of the deal and they'd just be quite exuberant in their posturing of worship.
Finally, one Sunday, this very diminutive girl comes up and says, "Hi, my name's Lacey, I have a note for you." And
she gives me this little note and along with it a CD. She says, "I'm in a band," and this is really before they
took off, y'know? I hadn't heard of them until this moment. I read the note and it starts with this, "Every
night we go into the pits of Hell and pull people out and your music has been an inspiration for us. It's very
bleak and dark where we are, and we need bits of light and your music has been that for us." So I was obviously moved.
When somebody says "I like your music" and it's useful in some sense, I was prone to give the CD a listen. So me and my
wife, on the way home from church, put the CD in, and - you know that first track man - when she hits that first chorus
and that scream happens, man? Every hair on the back on my neck was stickin' up! I was like, "You gotta be -- this
little girl?! That's unbelievable!" So we listened to it all that day, and then by that night, we were headed to the grocery
store, and I let Toni, my wife, run inside while I sat in the car still listening to it, and it got to this "All Around
Me" song, and immediately I thought, "Wow, this would be a great expression. This is a great song. The imagery
is so beautiful, this would be a good corporate experience for people." So then they blew up. At that time I thought,
"Oh man, this'll be great, I can cover this little band from Temple's stuff," and then a million-some-odd records later,
I'm like, "Well, if we do this song, we're going to have to repackage it in a way that feels like a rediscovery." So
we kind of went with that Mad World vibe. So that was sort of our musical model for how we could rediscover it.
And then also there's a tune on the Amelie soundtrack that if you hear it, you'd be like, "Oh, that's totally
where they were pointing to, too." So, between the two of them...
JFH (John): And isn't there also like thunder in the background?
David: Yes, it does sound like thunder, but that is actually people -- y'know the crowd that's in the
front intro section of "How He Loves?" That's the crowd noise from that song, but we just jacked with it so it sounds
JFH (John): Really? Cuz it does sound like rain and thunder. It's a good vibe. I like that...
David: Yeah! I do too. It's one of my favorite sections of the record. That into "How He Loves." You
finally get some of the intimacy... That would be one of my criticisms of the record is [I wish] we had a few more
moments that were stripped away and there was an intimacy present. I think that there could have been a couple of sections
where we did that, but it would have been too difficult.
JFH (John): Well, you could always do an acoustic EP.
David: That's very true.
JFH (John): But I think it makes those two songs more powerful.
David: Stand out. That is easily arguable.
JFH (John): And I haven't heard too many versions of "How He Loves" that I really
liked, and that one is honestly my favorite version that I've heard. I really like the vibe that you give it. Especially
paired with "All Around Me."
David: I do agree. I like it. It's a good moment on the record.
JFH (John): Now, you sing a lot about joy. Do you ever have those days when you
feel like you have to fight for joy.
David: Y'know, the bizarre thing is, I feel like most of the vocalizations of joy are statements of
hope. I think I'm a pretty bleak person.
JFH (John): Really?
David: Yeah. *laughs* My outlook is pretty bleak. I'm pretty cynical. And I'll see expressions
of even just childlike joy and that's a desire. So I feel like a lot of that's a hopefulness in the writing.
JFH (John): So in the process of singing about it, you are fighting for it.
David: Yeah. It's sort of the idea of the black spirituals, y'know? They would sing about this
place they wanted to be. And they'd almost sing themselves into it - is sort of how I look at that.
JFH (John): Interesting. Do you feel like, when you're singing some of these songs, that you do get there?
David: Uh... on occasion, yeah.
JFH (John): That's interesting. Cuz with a song like "You Are My Joy," I'll listen to it
and sing along, but wonder if I really know what it's like to be able to claim "You are my joy?"
David: Well, here's where that song comes out of... we were in an airport and we're riding on one of those
people-mover-things (moving walkway) and we're just standing there and it's been one of those days, y'know? Just not been
cool. And we looked out the window and see the plane we're getting on and watched all of our cases drop from, whatever it is,
ten feet from the little cargo door to the ground *laughs* I'm like, "Are you kidding me?! You've gotta
be kidding me. Insult to injury!" And this statement sort of came up in me, out of a pretty lame spot - not the cases being
dropped, but the day culminating in that moment, just felt like (John: ...the icing on the cake...)
Yeah. I dunno. This thing came out, like "Huh... Maybe I could sing myself to somewhere better."
JFH (John): What do you feel God has been teaching you lately?
David: How to confront each other properly. How to be confrontational in ways that are generous.
That would be it. How to speak truth in a way that is productive rather than destructive. Most of the time I'm not good
at it, but I'm trying.
JFH (John): Now, to get really serious..... What are some of your favorite
old school NES games?
David: Oh, wow, dude! You're doin' it! ... Well, all the typicals. I mean, Mario Bros. is
kinda "it." And Duck Hunt.
JFH (John): I never would have guessed by the sound effects you use in your
show -- and it's awesome, by the way, that you worked it into the record.
David: Thank you. Well, I think we figured out finally that we are very influenced by old video game
music. I think it's taken us a number of years to finally admit to it. *laughs*
JFH (John): There's nothing wrong with it!
David: Well, anytime we would hear any of the bleeps and blips, we just had this grin and "Ah, dude,
I love this!" And finally we pinpointed, "Well, I think we spent too many days in front of the TV at friends' houses
trying to save the Princess." It affected us.
David Crowder*Band's new album, Church Music, is available NOW wherever music is sold.