Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 11!
Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 11!

JFH Staff Book Review

The Boyd Bafflers Vol. 1

J.R. Underdown
The Boyd Bafflers Vol. 1

Genre: Mystery/Fiction
Page Count: 249 Pages
Street Date: March 26, 2021

Author J.R. Underdown is as versatile a creative as you are likely to find. Taking cues from a lifetime of movies, shows, music, stories, and other art forms from an early age, he has put much of that education to use as a songwriter, poet, reviewer, podcaster, and author. Utilizing these diverse influences, Underdown has already released a YA Fantasy Novel, Plethora, a self-published collection of poetry (Seasons So Far), two EPs on NoiseTrade, music reviews on, as well as guest appearances on the podcast, and short fiction published on and in Mystery Weekly Magazine.

J.R.'s newest endeavor is The Boyd Bafflers: Vol. 1, and is a collection of twelve short stories that follow two friends, Braxton and Jonah, as they seek out answers to various mysteries at their Bible College. The stories were compiled over years of plying his writing craft and based off of real-life influences and friendships. This served to give character depth without spending too much time on character development due to the brevity of each story. The "bafflers" themselves, range from lighthearted misunderstandings to kidnapping, while the tone never strays too far from the fare of television show Scooby-Doo, or The Hardy Boys novels of yesteryear.

Our two main characters Braxton Fife, the brainy homeschooler prone to superfluous arguments, and fellow freshman Jonah Underhill, who has a nose for mysteries, make for a great pair of friends and detectives. Sharing this love for "bafflers" brings them together and they quickly develop strong chemistry across the chronicles. Underdown's reoccurring supporting characters also serve to add additional flavor and camaraderie without clogging the narrative with too many people to keep up with.

The setting of most of the cases at the Seminary/Bible College was fresh and brought with it some fun inside jokes that this former Bible College student could appreciate, without totally excluding those who didn't share a similar experience. I definitely got a kick out of the name of the valley between the college and the seminary, which I won't spoil here but suffice to say is aptly and cleverly labeled. In fact, the cleverness of names, banter, and the spot-on depiction of former homeschooler Braxton, left this reviewer chuckling quite often and even produced a laugh-out-loud moment or two.

All in all, The Boyd Bafflers is a fun read that you can look forward to coming back to because of the brief length of each one. It's perfect for reading straight through or coming back every couple of days for a new dose of whimsy. I would highly recommend it for fans of precocious mysteries like the aforementioned Hardy Boys, Scooby-Doo, and Sherlock Holmes or just those who enjoy a good mystery with the clever interplay between characters, especially the middle school age group and up. With this being labeled as "Volume One," I certainly hope to hear more from our Boyd College detectives with a potential "Volume Two" very soon.

- Review date: 4/3/21, written by Josh Balogh of


. Publisher: Independently Published
. Page Count: 249 Pages
. Street Date: March 26, 2021
. Buy It: (Softcover)
. Buy It: (Kindle)


Leave a Comment



go to main Book review page


Check out the new EP from Darby Hughes!

Search JFH

This Wednesday, September 21, 2022
REVERE Onipotente / Omnipotent (feat. Lucy Grimble) - Single [Integrity]

This Friday, September 23, 2022
29:11 Worship Say It Again [DREAM Worship]
Anchor Hymns Be Unto Your Name - EP [Integrity]
Blanca The Heartbreak And The Healing [Curb/Word]
Bethel Music Simple [Bethel]
Ben Fuller Who I Am [Provident]
ICF Worship Treuer Gott - EP [Integrity]
Lakewood Music SHOUT! [Lakewood]
Tyson Mostenbocker Milk Teeth [Tooth & Nail]
Newsboys STAND (Deluxe) [Capitol CMG]

Maria Gilpin Rend Your Heart - Single [7Core Music]
Philippa Hanna Loved Me First - Single [Integrity]
Benjamin William Hastings Eden (Isn't Just Like You?) - Single [Capitol CMG]
David Leonard Good Lord (feat. Katy Nichole) - Single [Provident]
Matt Maher One Heart at a Time - Single [Provident]
Leigh Nash Made for This (Acoustic) - Single [Visionary]
Matt Redman Son of Suffering - Single [Integrity]

Next Friday, September 30, 2022
Cody Carnes God is Good! [Capitol CMG]
Disciple Back Again (2003) CD Re-Release [Girder]
Disciple By God (2001) CD Re-Release [Girder]
Disciple This Might Sting A Little CD Re-Release [Girder]
Disciple What Was I Thinking (1995) CD Re-Release [Girder]
JJ Hairston Believe Again [Tribl/JamesTown]
Evvie McKinney Love, Evvie McKinney [Capitol CMG]
SEU Worship Heart Cry [Provident]
WHATUPRG New Hollywood [Reach]
Zach Williams A Hundred Highways [Provident]
Ian Yates Between The Joy And The Sorrow: Part 2 [7Core Music]

Meredith Andrews Carry The World - Single [Word Worship]
Moriah Trust - Single [Cathedral Company]
For all release dates, click here!

Listen to the New Album By Before Flags!

Listen to the new album by Stephanie Haavik

Check out depositphotos for royalty free images