Listen to the new album from May Angeles!
Listen to the new album from May Angeles!

JFH Staff Review

The Question

Artist Info: Discography
Album length: 12 tracks: 41 minutes, 00 seconds
Street Date: August 2, 2005

It is titled The Question. And upon opening the linear notes, you are presented with the question "Where were you when I was…" Each track title completes the question (i.e. "So Cold I Could See My Breath," "The Weakest," "In a Lose, Lose Situation"). The artwork portrays a man pulling this question out of his coat and handing it to another man, who hands it to a woman, who hands it to a child, who hands it right back to the first man.

It seems the slightest bit cryptic until you take a glance at the lyrics. The Question, as a whole, seems poignantly directed at teenagers who wish to blame others for their pain and heartache. Major points to Emery for being the first band in a long time to state the obvious… the fault is their own. From the openly arrogant opener "So Cold I Could See My Breath" to the regretful closer "In a Win, Win Situation," The Question delivers the answer with a punch.

"So Cold I Could See My Breath" deals with the twisted way teenagers view relationships in our generation, "How quickly lust can pretend it's love… We're just the boys and girls who think they always know. With answers for the world, the ambiguity shows… Always trying what I can to be a child and not a man. My hands across your clothes. And me without a plan." Emery steps it up on The Question with such brutal honesty that you can almost hear a faint "Desperate times call for desperate measures" coming from your subconscious. It is one of those rare releases that moves you so deeply with it's unabashed honesty that you cannot help but dare to change. "Left with Alibis and Lying Eyes" literally puts you in the driver's seat of a car called "Running from your mistakes" as vocalists Toby Morelle and Devin Shelton scream at you from shotgun, "Drive! Drive! Drive! Drive! I don't want to get caught! We will say we're innocent. There is enough to prove we're not. They will believe anything."

And with this nothing-is-off-limits mentality, Christians take a hard blow from Emery as well on "Listening to Freddie Mercury," "We are all sisters and brothers until we find we don't believe the same, like… Gary is getting drunk to forget Sarah. Sarah is stealing money from her parents. Aaron is lying straight to Jon about Megan and the things that went on. Jessica is a gossip. Laura is a slut. Derrick hits Bridget, and Ben deals drugs. Seth spends his money gambling. Joey stopped praying. It is all the same thing. We are all the same people. With sinning hearts that make us equal…It is not our job to make people believe."

But as stated, by the disc's end, there is an overt sense of disgust and regret. "In a Win, Win Situation" ends with the line "I'd take it all back to start over again." There never really is a sense of hope. But that is not what Emery is trying to convey with The Question. They're pointing out the fault, and desperately crying out for us to take the next logical steps.

Remarkably, Emery conveys this emotion with minimal screaming. In contrast, The Question takes the melodic hardcore of The Weak's End and eliminates most, but not all, of the hardcore edge. This is a much catchier and accessible release. Plainly put, if you did not enjoy Emery's first release, there is a very good chance you will be able to get into The Question

The question of whether their sophomore effort matches up to their debut is redundant at best when faced with the hard reality of all that The Question is. Emery takes all that is wrong, twisted, and perverted in our culture today, puts it in a blender, and explains to us the mess in twelve tracks of satire. Kudos to the band for saying what desperately needs to said… The answer is in The Question.

- Review date: 8/5/05, written by Josh Taylor

Listen to the new album from People & Songs



Buy This CD Online

. Artist Info: Discography
. Record Label: Tooth and Nail Records
. Album length: 12 tracks, 41 minutes and 00 seconds
. Street Date: August 2, 2005
. Buy It:

  1. So Cold I Could See My Breath (3:31)
  2. Playing with Fire (3:51)
  3. Returning the Smile You Have Had from the Start (3:04)
  4. Studying Politics (3:30)
  5. Left with Alibis and Lying Eyes (3:22)
  6. Listening to Freddie Mercury (2:42)
  7. The Weakest (4:04)
  8. Miss Behavin' (3:17)
  9. In Between 4th and 2nd Street (0:32)
  10. The Terrible Secret (3:28)
  11. In a Lose, Lose Situation (3:56)
  12. In a Win, Win Situation (5:29)
spacer Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics



go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive


(JFH Sponsor Spot)



Listen to the new album from People & Songs

Search JFH

This Friday, July 23, 2021
Anberlin As You Found Me (Livestream) (independent)
Jonathan Cain Oh Lord Lead Us - Single [Identity/Fuel]
Canyon Hills Worship Something About The Name - Single [DREAM]
Colony House Automatic (feat. Fleurie) - Single [Roon]
Cross Point Music Never Going Back [Centricity]
Christine D’Clario All That Remains - Single [Capitol CMG]
Dreamers Land Of The Living - Single [DREAM]
Jason Dunn Billy Enforcee - Single (independent)
Equippers Worship Unified In Praise // All Glory (Live) - Single [DREAM]
Travis Greene Oil & Water (feat. Anthony Hamilton) - Single [Provident]
JUDAH. & J. Monty Irresponsible - Single [Capitol CMG]
Lonesome River Band Singing Up There: A Tribute to the Easter Brothers [Mountain Home Music]
Steven Malcolm All Is True - EP [4 Against 5 / Curb | Word]
Chris McClarney Speak To The Mountains EP [Capitol CMG]
Newsboys I Still Believe You're Good - Single [Capitol CMG]
Bryan Popin So Good 2 Me - Single (feat. Steven J. Collins) - Single [Little Boy Wonder]
Bryan Popin So Good 2 Me (LBWM Remix) - Single [feat. Steven J. Collins] - Single [Little Boy Wonder]
Social Club Misfits Feared By Hell (Reanimation) - EP [Capitol CMG]
Phil Thompson Lion of Judah [Integrity]
Carrie Underwood My Savior: LIVE From The Ryman DVD [UMG]
Village Lights Here is Our Hallelujah (feat. Sarah Kroger, Ike Ndolo & Ricky Vazquez) - Single [Integrity]

Next Thursday, July 29, 2021
Panther City Riots Say It Like You Mean It - Single (independent)

Next Friday, July 30, 2021
Coby James Mixtape Side B EP [Centricity]
Jonah 33 Bullet From A Gun - Single [Boleyn]
Vince Lichlyter Things I Need To Say - Single [Boleyn]
Make Sure Japanese Bonus Track - Single [Tooth & Nail]
NEEDTOBREATHE Into the Mystery [Centricity/Elektra]
Dottie Rambo It’s The Soul of Me (1968 Digital Reissue) [Provident/Sony]
Reba Rambo Reba Rambo (Digital Reissue) [eOne]
SongLab Simplicity (Live) - EP [DREAM]

For all release dates, click here!

Listen to the new album from Wade McNutt!

Listen to the new album from Jaime Masetta!