Listen to the new album by Elias Dummer!
Listen to the new album from Elias Dummer!

JFH Indie Review

JFH Indie Inspection Review



Street Date: 2010
Style: Progressive Rock
Artist Website:
Download It:

Inspiration and influence are heavy within CCM. Pointless and meaningless songs are scarcely heard and that's a good thing. For indie artist Pilgrimsprog, the brainchild of multi-instrumentalist and vocalist Scott Miller, there is no doubt that John Bunyan's The Pilgrim's Progress heavily influenced him, as he released his debut album, Pilgrimsprog. The album is broken up into two parts, much like Bunyan's story, and is reflected very creatively through utilization of fusing genres. The first portion of the album (from "Dream" to "I Believe") leans more towards a bleak and minor chord sound. "Overture" splits apart the two parts with a beautiful piano solo and gives a clear representation of change. The second portion of the album (from "Beautiful" to "Compline") sounds more hopeful while still reflecting the confrontations that the literary protagonist, Christian, faces. For a creative interpretation of a beloved story, it's an honest and a noticeably heartfelt effort. Musically, the album is a melting pot of styles that fans of Sufjan Stevens' instrumental work might really enjoy. Lyrically, the album is telling a story, much like a rock opera, so listeners should expect a loose structure but one that is clearly moving in a solid direction. Pilgrimsprog may not be a good fit for some listeners; but for creative storytellers and experimental instrumentalists, they might find something really interesting with this album.

- Review date: 6/23/14, written by Ryan Barbee of

Get the new book by Tanner Olson!


. Record Label: None
. Album length: 15 tracks: 57 minutes, 33 seconds
. Street Date: 2010
. Download It:

  1. Dream (5:09)
  2. Seek The Gate (3:29)
  3. SOD (3:16)
  4. Help (1:00)
  5. Gatekeeper (Acoustic) (3:22)
  6. I Believe (4:28)
  7. Overture (1:29)
  8. Beautiful (3:09)
  9. Confrontation (4:03)
  10. Giant Disaster (3:59)
  11. The River (4:04)
  12. Celestial City (10:37)
  13. Compline (2:05)
  14. Beautiful (Acoustic) (2:57)
  15. Dream (Acoustic) (4:28)



  • Jesus freak Hideout (Ryan Barbee): Why did you all decide to do an album based on Pilgrim's Progress?

    Scott Miller: In 2005-2006, my songwriting partner and I were starting to write prog songs for our band. I had recently picked up the Euro prog band Ayreon's Human Equation CD, where each person in the story is sung by a different vocalist. I was reading Pilgrim's Progress, and I envisioned it as a prog epic with multiple vocalists.

    I started writing demos of the first few songs. "Dream" has a chorus that says, "Is there a God in heaven, is there life after death? Is there a purpose in this life?" My friend said "you will never be able to play that at a Christian event or a church!" And the band decided that the song was too elaborate to do with our band mates and equipment. So I went off and finished it as a personal project.

  • JFH (Ryan): If you were Christian in Pilgrim's Progress, what character do you think you would see most often on your travel to the Celestial City?

    Scott: If it was my walk/life, I hope Evangelist or Gatekeeper would be who I would see repeatedly on the journey. In reality it would probably be Worldly Wise Man beckoning me off to the Detour. ("Detour" is a song on my second CD - "Do You Have Thanatophobia?". I include the song in the live set after "SOD" and before "Gatekeeper.")

  • JFH (Ryan): What song was the most challenging to record?

    Scott: "Celestial City" has a lot of orchestration, choir, and is 10+ minutes long. Most challenging instrumentally. Some of the other songs were difficult to finish, such as "Seek the Gate," which I rewrote about three times. The whole project took 4 years to write and record, from 2006-2010. There was a bleak period of about 8 months in the middle of that time where no one seemed to "get" it and I wasn't sure that I would finish it.

  • JFH (Ryan): If you were to make another album based on a book (other than the bible), what would it be?

    Scott: "The Great Divorce" by C.S. Lewis. Or "Holy War", also by John Bunyan.

  • JFH (Ryan): You clearly listen to a wide variety of music. What bands have had the most influence on you?

    Scott: Ayreon, as said above. Neal Morse is one of the biggest influences. His "?" album is amazing. Who would have thought that someone could write an album about the Tabernacle! "The Temple of the Living God" song from that album gets me every time. I have worn that CD out twice. Dream Theater is a huge influence. "Dream" and "SOD reflect that.

  • JFH (Ryan): What do you hope to accomplish with your music?

    Scott: I think that prog is the perfect vehicle for sharing faith. It allows grand themes, it is instrumentally interesting, and it seems to have depth, and intrigue people more than praise songs. The audience is different. I play these songs live, just me, a bunch of pedals, and a guitar synth. I play something on synth, lock it in and play over it. It allows more instrumentation. I play mostly non-Christian venues. And acknowledging people where they are - "is there a God in heaven?" - is honest, remarkably empowering, and gains credibility to be able to answer that question later in the set or one on one.

  • JFH (Ryan): If you could have breakfast at Tiffany's with anyone, who would it be and why? (And no… Audrey Hepburn and Jesus are not options)

    Scott: From history, it would be Martin Luther. I am intrigued how he was so spiritual, and yet so conflicted and depressed. From the present it would be Neal Morse. His courage to go solo as a Christian artist when there really were no Christian prog bands (with very limited Euro prog exceptions) is just amazing. His humor is quirky, almost British comedy in nature, and I can relate. I really respect him and I own all of his material.



    go to main Indie review page
    go to Indie Review Index


    Get the new book by Tanner Olson!

    Search JFH

    This Friday, September 18, 2020
    7eventh Time Down Questions - Single [BEC]
    A Jesus Church Take Your Throne [BEC Worship]
    Austin & Lindsey Adamec Can't Deny It - Single [Integrity]
    Apollo LTD Better - Single [Centricity]
    Cross Point Music Never Stop Singing - Single [Centricity]
    Disciple Love Letter Kill Shot (Deluxe) [Tooth & Nail]
    Fit for a King The Path [Solid State]
    Austin French Wake Up Sleeper EP [Fair Trade]
    Jordan Feliz Wounds - Single [Centricity]
    Jason Gray Right On Time - Single [Centricity]
    Koryn Hawthorne I AM [Provident]
    Hulvey Otherside - Single [Reach]
    Kari Jobe First Love (Live) EP [Capitol CMG]
    Tasha Layton Into the Sea EP [BEC]
    Ashlyn Levoy Something Better - Single [Centricity]
    Local Sound Won't Let Go - Single [Running Club/Integrity]
    Dr. James Mable Jr. The Journey 2.0 [eOne]
    Evvie McKinney Look No Further - Single [Motown Gospel]
    Chris Renzema Mercy - Single [Centricity]
    REVERE REVERE (Live) [Integrity]
    Seventh Day Slumber Unseen: The Lamb - EP [RockFest]
    SongLab My Favorite (Live From South Eden) - Single [DREAM]

    Next Friday, September 25, 2020
    Landry Cantrell Glasshouse [DREAM]
    Natalie Grant No Stranger [Curb/Word]
    Coby James Infinite - Single [Centricity]
    Bryon Juane Promise I'm Not Crazy EP [RMG]
    KB His Glory Alone [HGA/Essential Sound]
    Tasha Cobbs Leonard Royalty: Live At The Ryman [Motown Gospel]
    Jessy Elsa Palma Jehovah - Single [Integrity]
    Mr. Talkbox Playlist (independent)
    PEABOD Wonderful & Scary - Single [Centricity]
    Sarah Reeves Motions - Single [Curb/Word]
    Slick Shoes Rotation & Frequency [Tooth & Nail]
    WHATUPRG New Hollywood [Reach]

    For all release dates, click here!

    Listen to the new children's album from The Block Worship!

    Listen to the new album from Radio Friendly!