Listen to the new album from May Angeles!
Listen to the new album from May Angeles!

JFH Staff Review

Beautiful Lumps of Coal

Artist Info: Discography
Album length: 12 tracks: 41 minutes, 3 seconds
Street Date: March 25, 2003

In 1997, following a short stint in a little-known group called Benjamin, Tiffany Arbuckle started an industrial-flavored rock group named Plumb which received great attention in the Christian music industry. The group underwent several member changes before releasing a second record in 1999, entitled candycoatedwaterdrops, showcasing a more pop/rock feel. In 2000, Plumb made the decision to leave her previous record label, and a greatest hits project, entitled The Best of Plumb was released to fulfill contract obligations. Plumb married later that year (becoming Tiffany Arbuckle Lee), and until 2002, searched for a new home label before coming to rest with Curb Records. Now, in 2003, minus the band and going solely by just Plumb, the much delayed and anticipated follow-up to candycoated... finally graces shelves. So has it been worth the wait?

Beautiful Lumps of Coal opens with "Free," a pop/rocker about old relationships that has Plumb crying out "I'm free / to be the girl you tried to steal from me." A song Plumb admits she wrote while relaxing in her bathtub, "Free" is Plumb's response to all of her old boyfriends, her previous management, and her previous record company and what all of them thought she was all about as a person and an artist. "Sink 'N Swim" is Plumb's take on unconditional love and the the idea of surviving tough times together, namely in her relationship with her husband Jeremy. "Without You" is a catchy pop tune inspired by an argument Plumb once had with Jeremy before they were married. According to Plumb, they had left each other without settling things, leaving her to realize how much he meant to her and the criticality of leaving on sour terms. "Boys Don't Cry" is a highlight on Beautiful Lumps..., a standout pop rock anthem inspired by a boy Plumb's husband had counseled who felt neglected by his parents and that they cared more about their reputation than their child and things he struggled through. The emotional track fits well among Plumb's signature relationship-focused tracks. "Hold Me" was originally written by Plumb for another artist but she wasn't comfortable with how the lyrics sounded before changing them to what appears here. A bass-laden intro gives way to a rock tune that has now come to be moreso about Plumb's wedding night than anything else, "Hold me til morning / Love me right now... / And I will never be the same again... / Tonight lasts forever..."

"Taken" is a delicate and catchy pop tune that Plumb offers as a tribute to one of Jeremy's ex-girlfriends who she credits to positive changes that were made in his character. "Nine months after [Jeremy and I] started dating," Plumb says in her official bio, "she drowned while swimming in a river. She was just 19 or 20 years old. ...Had he not met her before me, I probably wouldn't have looked twice at him, so I was thankful for her for being the influence she was. Not many people write songs about their husband's ex-girlfriends, but Jeremy and I still hold her safe inside. It's all in that song, which is not so much a 'goodbye' as 'see your later'..."

"Nice Naive and Beautiful" is a somber ballad for the abused in which she encourages listeners who can relate that they're not going through pain for no reason, but have the opportunity to take it and use it for their betterment. Here Plumb stretches her vocal abilities and at times slips into a few moments where Jewel would sure to be proud. "Unnoticed" is a rock track about the unselfish who are often overlooked while "Real" is a lament about our sex-driven society that is missing out on the true beauty of life. "Love 'Em & Kiss 'Em" is a home recording of mother speaking to a three-year-old Plumb in 1977 about marriage, making the perfect intro for the beautiful and delicate piano-driven "Go," a song about her parents having to let her go as she married Jeremy.

Beautiful Lumps of Coal is an excellent third installment in the musical chronicles of Tiffany Arbuckle Lee. Musically, it's a step in another direction for Arbuckle Lee, as she continues to mature as a songwriter and musician. Lyrically, Plumb continues to tackle sensitive topics that are easy to relate to that have been given a whole new spin since her marriage. Longtime fans have much rejoicing to do over Beautiful Lumps of Coal and new listeners who appreciate meaningful female-fronted pop/rock won't want to miss out on this release.

- Review date: 3/22/03, written by John DiBiase

Listen to the new album from People & Songs

Plumb CD

Buy This CD Online

. Artist Info: Discography
. Record Label: Curb Records
. Album length: 12 tracks, 41 minutes and 3 seconds
. Street Date: March 25, 2003
. Buy It:

  1. Free
  2. Sink 'N Swim
  3. Without You
  4. Boys Don't Cry
  5. Hold Me
  6. Walk Away
  7. Taken
  8. Nice Naive and Beautiful
  9. Unnoticed
  10. Real
  11. Love 'Em & Kiss 'Em
  12. Go
spacer Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics




go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive


(JFH Sponsor Spot)



Listen to the new album from People & Songs

Search JFH

This Friday, July 23, 2021
Anberlin As You Found Me (Livestream) (independent)
Bethany Barnard Who Else - Single (independent)
Jonathan Cain Oh Lord Lead Us - Single [Identity/Fuel]
Canyon Hills Worship Something About The Name - Single [DREAM]
Colony House Automatic (feat. Fleurie) - Single [Roon]
Cross Point Music Never Going Back [Centricity]
Christine DíClario All That Remains - Single [Capitol CMG]
Dreamers Land Of The Living - Single [DREAM]
Jason Dunn Billy Enforcee - Single (independent)
Equippers Worship Unified In Praise // All Glory (Live) - Single [DREAM]
Travis Greene Oil & Water (feat. Anthony Hamilton) - Single [Provident]
JUDAH. & J. Monty Irresponsible - Single [Capitol CMG]
Lonesome River Band Singing Up There: A Tribute to the Easter Brothers [Mountain Home Music]
Steven Malcolm All Is True - EP [4 Against 5 / Curb | Word]
Chris McClarney Speak To The Mountains EP [Capitol CMG]
Newsboys I Still Believe You're Good - Single [Capitol CMG]
Bryan Popin So Good 2 Me - Single (feat. Steven J. Collins) - Single [Little Boy Wonder]
Bryan Popin So Good 2 Me (LBWM Remix) - Single [feat. Steven J. Collins] - Single [Little Boy Wonder]
Shane & Shane Psalms, Hymns, And Spiritual Songs, Vol. 1 [Wellhouse]
Social Club Misfits Feared By Hell (Reanimation) - EP [Capitol CMG]
Phil Thompson Lion of Judah [Integrity]
Carrie Underwood My Savior: LIVE From The Ryman DVD [UMG]
Village Lights Here is Our Hallelujah (feat. Sarah Kroger, Ike Ndolo & Ricky Vazquez) - Single [Integrity]

Next Thursday, July 29, 2021
Panther City Riots Say It Like You Mean It - Single (independent)

Next Friday, July 30, 2021
Coby James Mixtape Side B EP [Centricity]
Jonah 33 Bullet From A Gun - Single [Boleyn]
Vince Lichlyter Things I Need To Say - Single [Boleyn]
Make Sure Japanese Bonus Track - Single [Tooth & Nail]
NEEDTOBREATHE Into the Mystery [Centricity/Elektra]
Dottie Rambo Itís The Soul of Me (1968 Digital Reissue) [Provident/Sony]
Reba Rambo Reba Rambo (Digital Reissue) [eOne]
SongLab Simplicity (Live) - EP [DREAM]

For all release dates, click here!

Listen to the new album from Wade McNutt!

Listen to the new album from Jaime Masetta!