Jesusfreakhideout.com celebrates 30 Years online in 2026... Get Your Music - and everything else - on Amazon! All purchases made on Amazon through this link earn a commission for Jesusfreakhideout.com!
Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation August 13, 2026!

  Jesusfreakhideout.com 5-Star Review

  JFH 5-Star Review


Sixpence None the Richer
This Beautiful Mess



Artist Info: Discography
Genre(s): Indie / Alternative
Album length: 12 tracks: 49 minutes, 44 seconds
Street Date: July 15, 1995


 
  
ThisBeautifulMess
READER RATING:  ThisBeautifulMess
– / 5.0 (0 votes)

Alternative band Sixpence None the Richer is a melancholy soul's perfect match. While I understand some not connecting with the wistful and occasionally gloomy vibe, they have been a source of encouragement and solidarity for my often restless soul for many years. I'm grateful they have been a band that only grows more poignant with each passing season cemented now as an all-time favorite.

Oh, and they can rock. Yes. This their sophomore album, This Beautiful Mess, is the culmination of them becoming a full band adding three official members that all put a stamp on the evolving sound. Tess Wiley joined to add rhythm guitar, additional female harmonies, and a more aggressive rock edge. Additionally, J.J. Plasencio jumps in on bass adding some thump, and Dale Baker on drums adds his respective jazz background to round out the rhythm section.

For my money, the strongest section of this rock-solid album is the first four tracks where they showcase a more aggressive edge musically that is juxtaposed perfectly with Leigh's angelic voice. But that doesn't mean she can't dig deep and belt; she is in no way overpowered by the music. "Angeltread," "Love, Salvation, The Fear of Death" (what a cool bass line), and "Within a Room Somewhere" could easily compete for being the album's best song, but my heart has always been with "Within a Room Somewhere." To this day, it's still my overall favorite song by the band.

After that four-song run, the band wisely slows the tempo, allowing for a cool-down period ending on another rocking note with "Drifting" and closer "I Can't Explain." But the middle section is also where we get Leigh's first real attempt at lyrics in "The Garden," and Tess Wiley's "Disconnect," which on the past few listens of TBM has become a newer favorite. There's just something about the hook that... well... hooks me. Also, "Thought Menagerie" is a pleasant jangly pop ride that fits perfectly at this juncture in the latter half of the album.

All things considered, This Beautiful Mess is a big bump in quality from their debut, and showcases a band that has a better feel for who they want to be musically. Each member adds something noteworthy, and it makes for what I think is a great album in CCM, released within my favorite year for music and in my favorite decade of music. This is a record that stands up to anything going on in the mainstream at the time and I wish it had been recognized as such. That said, I look forward to the continued discovery of nuance with each successive listen, and cannot recommend it enough to those who may have missed it at the time of its release. This is a must for fans of 90s alternative rock, and jangle pop, and those digging deeper into the history of Contemporary Christian Music.




(JFH Sponsor Spot)

Check out JFH's Lloyd in his first-ever childrens book!

JFH Reader Review




Sixpense None the Richer's second album is one of their most notable. Although it was their self-titled album that really sky-rocketed them to success, it was This Beautiful Mess that really established a fan base for them and is considered by many fans to this day to be their best album. The deep, dreamy music along with Leigh's silky smooth vocals and Matt Slocum's deep songwriting that made this album a musical journey not to be forgotten. Almost every song on this album is amazing in its own right with one great song after another. My only complaint about this album is that the unique melancholy nature of the album gets a bit tiresome after a dozen songs, but the album's unique musical style is what gives it its charm. The band truly found something that works with this album, it just seems like they used what works a little too much. However, with almost every song being an epic musical movement, you can't go wrong with this Sixpence classic.


Record Label: R.E.X. Music
Album length: 12 tracks: 49 minutes, 44 seconds
Street Date: July 15, 1995
Buy It: Apple Music
Buy It: Amazon.com (CD)
Buy It: Amazon.com (Vinyl)
Buy It: Amazon Music (MP3)

  1. Angeltread (3:28)LYRICS
  2. Love, Salvation, The Fear Of Death (3:51)LYRICS
  3. Bleeding (5:04)LYRICS
  4. Within A Room Somewhere (5:06)LYRICS
  5. Melting Alone (4:03)LYRICS
  6. Circle Of Error (5:04)LYRICS
  7. The Garden (4:03)LYRICS
  8. Disconnect (4:20)LYRICS
  9. Thought Menagerie (3:11)LYRICS
  10. Maybe Tomorrow (4:22)LYRICS
  11. Drifting (3:42)LYRICS
  12. I Can't Explain (3:25)LYRICS

Listen to the Music with Spotify

Loading Spotify player…
If it stays blank, your network, privacy settings, or an ad-blocker may be blocking embeds.

 

go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive

 

 

                 
Check out JFH's Lloyd in his first-ever childrens book!

Search JFH



This Tuesday, November 10
SINGLES
Seth Davey A New Dawn - Single (independent)

This Wednesday, November 11
ALBUMS
Anberlin CURRENCY [Equal Vision]

This Friday, November 13
ALBUMS
Blanca A Christmas to Remember [Curb]
Jeremy Camp, Adrienne Camp A Camp Family Christmas [Capitol CMG]
Amy Grant Tennessee Christmas (10th Anniversary Edition) [AG]
Lily Hooten Promise Land [Anotherland]
The Lofi Christian & Commons Worship The Commons Lofi (independent)
outr.cty Green Skies, Blue Grass [Syntax]
Jackie Hill Perry Still Blameless (Deluxe) [Velvet Blue]
Leem of the Earth See [Velvet Blue]
Tye Tribbett V20: First Semester (Live) [Freligious]
Calum Wood Christmas Songs from the Kitchen Table, Vol. 2 (independent)

SINGLES
Bethel Music, Emmy Rose Noel (He Is Born) - Single [Bethel]
Elan Brio Jewels (feat. George Jones III) - Single [Polished Arrow]
Chris Caro 10 YEARS IN A MINUTE - Single [Syntax]
Cody Carnes + Kari Jobe Carnes Doxology (All Praise) - Single [Sparrow]
Cutright The Curtain - Single [Syntax]
Jordan Feliz Fast - Single [Centricity]
Rachelle Fletcher Water in My Desert (Acoustic Version) - Single (independent)
Forrest Frank My Little Miracle (ft. ZVC) - Single [River House]
Matt Gorman Nature of the Beast - Single [By Design]
Josh Grove Glory - Single (independent)
Joe & Beth I Stand Forgiven - Single (independent)
Elle Limebear Give Me Joy (Live from O2 Shepherd's Bush Empire) - Single [Decca]
Living Again Get This Far - Single (independent)
Baylee Lynn Save Me A Seat - Single [Interscope]
Steven Malcolm Prey On Me - Single [IVAV / Curb]
Michelle Williams, Kenny Lattimore God With Us - Single [Tyscot]
Hunter Plake Silver Bells - Single [BEC]
Matthew Plante OVEN MITT! - Single [Dream]
Jenna Raine Frosty / A Baby Was Born - Double Single [Warner]
Magdalene Rose the terrifying reality of it all - Single [Rockfest]
Sleeping At Last Merry Christmas, Darling - Single (independent)
Jordan St. Cyr Angels We Have Heard On High - Single [BEC]
Lauren Talley While There's Time - Single [Horizon]
Amelia Wells At Your Feet - Single [Hope Lane]
Phil Wickham O Holy Night (Adoration) - Single [Fair Trade]
Natasha Zimbaro Emmanuel - Single [Wings]

VINYL
Anberlin CURRENCY Vinyl [Equal Vision]

Next Thursday, November 19
ALBUMS
NEEDTOBREATHE The Long Surrender and The Fellow Passengers of Pain [UMG]

Next Friday, November 20
ALBUMS
Gabrielle Lovelace The Secret of Christmas [Old Bear]
Mountains in the Sea Breakthrough - EP [Dream]
New Wine Worship Ready For More - EP (independent)
The Rogers Family Let's Sing a Song About Jesus [Horizon]
Phil Wickham Hallelujah! It's Christmas Again! [Fair Trade]
Will Morrison, Calm Worship Collective Christmas Music - Instrumental Piano Holiday Songs (independent)

SINGLES
Francesca Battistelli Messiah (Cinematic) - Single [Curb]
Gracie Binion O Holy Night - Single [BEC]
John Long love deep - Single (independent)
Chandler Marie Merry Christmas Mary - Single (independent)
Hunter Plake Silent Night - Single [BEC]
Matthew Plante PRAISE DANCE! - Single [Dream]
Run51 Wishlist - Single [Dream]
Mike Weaver Homecoming - Single [Curb]

For all release dates, click here!
 

All sales made through this link support Jesusfreakhideout.com
All materials copyright of Jesusfreakhideout.com   ©1996-2026 Jesus freak Hideout. *Celebrating 30 Years* All Rights Reserved. | Privacy Policy