Listen to the new album by Katie Lighty!
Listen to the new album by Katie Lighty!

JFH Staff Review

Red Umbrella
Living and Surviving

---> Artist Info: Discography
Album length: 10 tracks: 32 minutes, 00 seconds
Street Date: October 2, 2008

I remember when I had first heard of Red Umbrella. Recommended to me by a friend who had recently seen the Canadian band in concert as well as picked up their debut record, I looked into them and I liked what I heard. With that said, I had high hopes for their follow up, Living and Surviving, but was, and still am, quite surprised by the results.

To start with, Red Umbrella has changed their sound significantly since Wishing For Boardwalk. Gone are the pure alternative rock melodies, and instead we get a synth-laden pop/rock sophomore offering. While they pull off the new sound well, there is an element to their old style that is somewhat missed. While it's definitely a fair statement to say that Red Umbrella has been trying to be progressive with their sound, this is almost so much of a change that it's a little hard to take it all in. This is similar to Family Force 5's genre change between their first and second record: Business Up Front, Party In the Back majored in the crunk rock realm, while Dance or Die left that sound behind and opted for a more electronic dance record. While I like both sounds, there is such a difference between the styles that it's almost a surreal feeling, and it's hard to get used to the new sound while still missing the old one. The same principle applies here.

This isn't to say that this is an entirely different band than we first heard on Wishing For Boardwalk. We are still treated to the unmistakable trademark vocals of Jeremy Michaelis as well as the quirky lyrics we have come to know and love from the Canadians. Some standouts on Living and Surviving include "Prison Side," a curious tale of a criminal, "Beckoning," with an undeniable beat, and "Crazy (All Of Me)," which is odd lyrically, but in a good, mysterious way.

One very apparent flaw is found in the track "Boompop." While the message of the song is admirable, there's a sudden rap from labelmate Playdough that rears its head in the middle of the song, and while it may have been an attempt to be different, it just sounds grossly out of place. Also, the appearance of the cover song "Turn! Turn! Turn!" (originally by the Byrds) is a tad disappointing. While it's done well enough and it's not a bad track by any means, it serves as the eighth of only ten tracks on the record. With only nine of the tracks here being originals, it's a little inadequate on the song quantity front. It's only a 32-minute long disc, too, so Living And Surviving is done and over a little too quickly. An addition of even one more track would have helped fix these problems.

Red Umbrella deserves some props. They attempted to do something different with their music and be as unique as possible, and that's admirable. Hopefully, Red Umbrella will develop more on this sound (as opposed to changing genres again) and make it something amazing, but for now, they've put together an eccentric album that's worth a listen for old and new fans of the band.

- Review date: 7/7/09, written by Roger Gelwicks of

Listen to the new album from Jack Izaak!


. Record Label: 7 Spin Music
. Album length: 10 tracks: 32 minutes, 00 seconds
. Street Date: October 2, 2008
. Buy It:
. Buy It: iTunes

  1. Prison Side (3:19)
  2. Intervention (3:14)
  3. Forest Fire (2:45)
  4. Beckoning (3:36)
  5. Boompop (3:02)
  6. Living & Surviving (2:58)
  7. Whisper All of Your Love (2:51)
  8. Turn Turn Turn (4:02)
  9. Crazy (All of Me) (3:22)
  10. Babbling Brook (2:51)



go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive


(JFH Sponsor Spot)



Listen to the new album from Jack Izaak!

Search JFH

This Monday, August 3, 2020
Jonah Fear (feat. Anomaly) - Single (independent)

This Friday, August 7, 2020
Apollo LTD Patience - Single [Centricity]
Disciple Darkness Dies - Single [Tooth & Nail]
Grandpa Loves Rhinos Searching in the Sarchasm [Indie Vision Music]
Jason Gray Glory Days - Single [Centricity]
Coby James Whatever - Single [Centricity]
Lydia Laird Lydia Laird - EP [Provident]
North Point Worship Praise Your Name [Centricity]
John Schlitt Go Vinyl [4K]
Seventh Day Slumber Unseen: The Lion - EP [Rockfest]
We The Kingdom Holy Water [Capitol CMG]

Next Thursday, August 13, 2020
Various Artists Songs We've Been Trying to Tell You About (And Others We Haven't), Volume 9 [JFH Music]

Next Friday, August 14, 2020
Bride Drop (25th Anniversary Edition) [Girder Records]
Tori Kelly Solitude EP [Capitol]
Life.Church Worship Jesus Is Near EP [DREAM Worship]
PEABOD Heavenly Father - Single [Centricity]
Kim Walker-Smith Wild Heart (Live) [Sparrow/Jesus Culture]

For all release dates, click here!

Listen to the new single from Melanie Waldman!

Listen to the new album from The Grace Collective!