Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 13!
Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 13!

JFH Music Review


Skillet, 'Revolution'
CLICK COVER TO ENLARGE

Skillet
Revolution



Artist Info: Discography
Genre(s): Rock / Alternative
Album length: 10 tracks: 35 minutes, 3 seconds
Street Date: November 1, 2024


READER RATING:   


Skillet is an artist that needs no introduction. Soon to be hitting the three-decade mark as a band (in various membership combinations, but always with the distinct vision and voice of lead singer and lyricist John Cooper at the helm), the group has managed to surf the changing tides of the music industry and remain relevant and consistent with their musical and live output from day one.

Alas, their new album Revolution finds the group treading water musically and thematically at best and pandering to an unknown demographic at worst with a few questionable theological lyrics and pseudo-political ramblings that (at times) sound just generic enough to be considered revolutionary by any side that wants to claim them.

And it all starts right away. The album kicks off with "Showtime," a typically blistering opening track from this band that, taken at face value, has troubling theological overtones: "Make my mark, no apologies / A day in the life, a revolutionary / Here we go, here we go, here we go / My life, high life / King over my empire / Nothing's gonna stop me / It's show (Show) time (Time) / One chance, one shot / Talk is cheap, so what you got? / World is gonna watch me / It's show (Show) time (Time)." To be fair, there are perhaps some directions that Cooper meant these lyrics to be heard in (perhaps an encouragement to not simply be a victim or have a passive attitude in life), but this potential perspective is largely lost in the "my life," "king over my empire" sloganeering that is the antithesis of the gospel message of surrendering one's own kingdom to Jesus and His call on our life to lay it down. This is a long way from Cooper's lyrics in "Gasoline," from the band's first album released 28 years ago, "You want to, you want to / Soak my heart in gasoline / Light a match and consume me / Soak my pride in gasoline / all of you and none of me." Skillet has been drifting into questionable messaging for a number of albums now, and opening Revolution with this track is a statement of purpose that should ring alarm bells. Nuance matters; context matters. And shouting a message that may feel good but has troubling undertones matters.

First single "Unpopular" features another bit of bravado that fits in the classic youth group methodology of encouraging the listener to value taking up unpopular opinions and viewpoints, but lacks any sort of lyrical foundation as to what those opinions and viewpoints may be: "Unpopular, unpopular / Call me out, clasp down / Can't supplement true facts / Have you heard? I'm a commoner / Got my family, sanity, everything I need / If freedom is disease, who would ever wanna be popular? / For what it's worth, I think today's a good day to be unpopular." This sort of well-meaning advice is actually problematic if divorced from context, because someone could hold all sorts of troubling viewpoints and cling to the would-be-virtue of "I must be right about this if it's an unpopular opinion." Again, context matters here. The idea of standing up for what is right no matter what the crowd may say is a noble and biblical idea. This advice, shouted against heavy metal guitars without a shred of nuance in a politically divided time is suspect and irresponsible. The headlines of our times are filled with those who have taken troubling viewpoints on critical, nuanced issues and have remained inflexible and contrarian to reason and common sense in the name of being "unpopular." This type of bumper sticker logic in the guise of a three-minute rock song is just lacking.

This hackneyed, quasi-political nonsense finds its nadir in "All That Matters," an inoffensive set of conservative dog whistles that drags out the tired "family, faith, freedom" alliteration (three noble concepts indeed) and tries to polish them up with a tuneless song that sounds as if it was written by ChatGPT to appeal to a conservative demographic without being too overt: "My faith, my family, my freedom / That's what's backin' me / Gives me a reason for living / I gotta fight for what I believe in, believe it / Love loyalty / I pledge fidelity / In this land of liberty, it's everything / My faith, my family, my freedom's / All that matters to me." This type of t-shirt tagline writing is beneath an artist who's been in the business as long as Skillet has. The use of "war imagery" here is troubling, too. For people of faith to blithely use fighting rhetoric like this in a heated time, politically speaking, is irresponsible at best and reckless at worst. (And Skillet releasing this album a few days before a contentious election seems to be further indication that they would like the album to be associated with the current political context.) Closing track "Death Defier" is not as egregiously troublesome in its lyrics as some songs here, but still promotes an unhealthy, triumphant viewpoint that is devoid of any gospel awareness at all.

There are a few moments where genuine sentiment breaks through all the propaganda. The sincerely heartfelt "Happy Wedding Day (Alex's Song)" is a wonderful reflection on the Coopers' daughter's wedding and finds John Cooper at his lyrical best: "Leave the dishes out and we'd put you to bed / Say no to one more story that I wish I'd of read / I didn't know then it'd come to an end / And I want it back now / We started out with dreams and love and nothing more / We ate from paper bags and we slept on the floor / Sometimes we weren't sure 'bout this adventure / But you made us so proud / I blinked, it went faster than a freight train / Happy wedding day." Any father would be proud to write such a tear-jerking song, and the little details, like "eating from a paper bag," make for a well-rounded picture of life on the road with a family in tow. And "Defector" is a nice throwback to the worship-adjacent tunes of past albums like Hey You, I love Your Soul and Alien Youth.

But despite those good moments, the theological and ideological red flags on Revolution are too many to overlook. Bumper sticker lyrics may say something in a sharp and clever way, but they rarely promote introspection, conversation, or a healthy contemplation of complex subjects. Skillet is capable of much more and, given the massive platform they have rightfully earned through years of earnest hard work, has a responsibility to sing about so much more and raise the conversation for their listeners in a constructive and meaningful way. With Revolution, the band manages through their intense inoffensiveness and lack of a viewpoint to say nothing, and to say it very loudly.

- Review date: 11/3/24, written by Alex Caldwell of Jesusfreakhideout.com



(JFH Sponsor Spot)

Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 13!

 

JFH Staff's Second Opinion



Skillet remains one of the most popular bands in Christian music's history. That's undeniable. Critics have been less enthusiastic since Comatose, and you can count this one among them. However, they have earned the right to a fair shake, and I'm always rooting for them. Unfortunately, this is a step back from their last two offerings. After five listens, Revolution is my least favorite Skillet album yet. Musically, we get more of the same, and that's not bad per se. The drums pound, the guitars shred, the vocals soar. There are a few standouts musically like the title track, opener "Showtime" with its electronic flourishes and guitar solo, "Not Afraid" with its chugging defiance, and the best lyrical track, "Fire Inside of Me," all shine. Additionally, it was nice to see the sentimental side of John in his song for his daughter, "Happy Wedding Day."

One of the more minor criticisms, that's more a preference, was the lack of Ledger on vocals. Her clarion call voice is a nice balance to John's throaty roar, and this album needed more of her presence. All in all though, the biggest letdown is lyrical. Cooper and company have never been world-class lyricists, but Revolution treads close to cliche more than it doesn't. The biggest blemish is the try at playfulness on "Unpopular." They aren't known for levity, so to try it on at this point makes it destined to be misunderstood. I just want Cooper to dig a little deeper, and share a little more of himself, something specific. A few adrenaline-juicing jams are fine, but how about more heartfelt sentiments like "Happy Wedding Day?" What of John's struggles and victories in marriage or parenting? Or perhaps a story of a fan told through song (like "The Last Night")? Ultimately, this longtime listener likes roughly half the album. I will playlist a handful of songs from Revolution, but don't see myself returning to spin the whole thing very often. - Review date: 11/3/24, Josh Balogh of Jesusfreakhideout.com

 

JFH Staff's Additional 2 Cents


    The last handful of Skillet albums have been a little bumpy; between uneven writing and an overreliance on recycled soundscapes, there has been as much to critique as to celebrate. Unfortunately, Revolution is no different and is somewhat marred by bookending "Showtime" and "Death Defier," the two most braggadocious and theologically messy tracks. I take no overt issue with most of Cooper's political messaging and theme, and even though a little cheesy, tracks such as "All That Matters" can be refreshing.

Thankfully, there are also some highlights sprinkled throughout, both in songs ("Ash in the Wind," "Happy Wedding Day") and lyrics ("I wanna change the world, I wanna save the world / but I can't even save myself / Is it too late to ask for help? / My soul's asleep, light the fire inside of me," "The highlight of the night was to hear you laugh / Guess we made it, but it's a little quiet now / Planes, trains, buses they were all you knew / Companions, best friends, survivors too").

Ultimately, Revolution is a mixed effort, and listeners should exercise discernment when listening in order to divine and glean the worthwhile content. - 11/2/24 David Craft


    As an original Panhead with the band's self-titled debut in 1996, I found Skillet a tour de force to watch as they grew from their raw grunge days as a trio to the more electronic-infused rock days that followed, and into their symphonic rock phase that began with Collide. But with the monster success of 2006's Comatose, Skillet became a mainstream hero with their follow-up Awake, bringing their bold faith-filled message to the masses. But after such a serious turn taken with the fantastic 2003 rocker Collide, the band has only continued to get more extravagant and bombastic with each succeeding album. 2024's Revolution is no different, with the aforementioned boldness coming off more abrasive than inspiring (whereas, the songs of Collide continue to inspire over 20 years later). However, the track that shines the brightest on the band's latest effort is the extremely personal and emotional ballad written for the Coopers' daughter Alex's wedding day, which easily pulls at the heartstrings of any parent seeing their child growing into an adult and forging their own path. But, with each new album since the late 2000's, the maturity the band once showed seems to be nothing more than a distant memory. Anyone who's been enjoying the last couple raucous albums from Skillet should be thrilled to hoist their flag and join their latest Revolution, but to anyone hoping to see the band return to more gritty roots may have to keep waiting, should that time ever come. - 11/2/24 John DiBiase

 

 

. Record Label: Hear It Loud Records (independent)
. Album length: 10 tracks: 35 minutes, 3 seconds
. Street Date: November 1, 2024
. Buy It: Apple Music
. Buy It: Amazon.com (CD)
. Buy It: Amazon.com (Vinyl)
. Buy It: Amazon Music (MP3)

  1. Showtime (3:33)
  2. Unpopular (3:06)
  3. All That Matters (3:28)
  4. Not Afraid (3:14)
  5. Revolution (3:06)
  6. Ash In The Wind (3:52)
  7. Fire Inside of Me (3:53)
  8. Defector (3:20)
  9. Happy Wedding Day (Alex's Song) (3:58)
  10. Death Defier (3:37)

 

 

 



Leave a Comment

 

 

go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive

 


(JFH Sponsor Spot)

 

 

                 
Get the new FREE JFH MP3 compilation -- Vol. 13!

Search JFH




This Friday, November 8, 2024
ALBUMS
Gabby Barrett Carols and Candlelight [Warner Music Nashville]
CXMMXNS CXMMXNS Chapter 1 - EP [Essential Worship]
New Hope Oahu There Is One - EP [DREAM]
Neal Morse & The Resonance No Hill For A Climber [InsideOut]
TAKE Time Bomb [Resuscitation Records]
Lauren Talley A Lauren Talley Christmas [Horizon]

SINGLES
Cory Asbury I Hope You Dance - Single [BEC]
Jordan Kauflin, Laura Story Approach, My Soul - Single [Getty]
Sam Bowman & GLADDEN Misfit Toys - Single [DREAM]
Wavorly Enemies - Single (independent)

VINYL
Michael W. Smith Every Christmas Vinyl [Rocketown]
Stryper To Hell with the Amps Vinyl [Frontiers]
TAKE Time Bomb Vinyl [Resuscitation Records]

DVD
Stryper To Hell with the Amps Blu-Ray [Frontiers]

Next Friday, November 15, 2024
ALBUMS
Dolly Parton & Family Smoky Mountain DNA – Family, Faith & Fables [Owepar Entertainment]
The Lore Family Faith Over Fear [Horizon]
Fernando Ortega For All the Saints - EP (independent)
Earnest Pugh Worth is the Lamb
We Are Messengers Rejoice! (A Celtic Christmas) - EP [Curb]
Paul Wright III Reverie [United Alliance]

SINGLES
Big Dismal Here In My Heart - Single (independent)
Hannah Kerr It Came Upon A Midnight Clear - Single [Curb]
Olivia Lane Silent Night - Single [BEC]
Tasha Layton Wake Up It's Christmas - Single [BEC]
Jamie MacDonald A Million Chances - Single [Capitol CMG]
Ronnie Martin On Christmas Morning - Single [Velvet Blue]
Hunter Plake Daylight - Single [BEC]
Jordan St. Cyr Christ is Here - Single [BEC]

VINYL
Sixpence None the Richer Divine Discontent Vinyl [Word]



For all release dates, click here!
 



Check out the new album from Taylor Holland Armstrong!



Listen to the new Single from Second Adam and the New Creations!

Check out depositphotos for royalty free images