Listen to the new album by Elias Dummer!
Listen to the new album from Elias Dummer!

JFH Staff Review

MercyMe, Welcome To The New

Welcome To The New

Artist Info: Discography
Genre(s): Contemporary / Pop / Pop Rock
Album length: 10 tracks: 40 minutes, 48 seconds
Street Date: April 8, 2014

It is no great secret that one of the biggest drawbacks of many of today's most popular artists in CCM is monotony in sound and style. Who amongst CCM fans hasn't turned on a Christian radio station and, upon hearing a song otherwise unknown to them, been able to predict the general song structure, dynamic shifts, vocal changes, or even amount of lyrical repetition of whatever song is gracing their ears? In the past, MercyMe has not been innocent of perpetuating that flaw, as they have arguably seen more success on CCM radio in the past decade than any other artist (with 11 Billboard chart-toppers serving as evidence). However, they have also shown more willingness to throw a changeup from time to time than most AC/Pop artists, with one notable example being their quick-tempo driving pop song "Move" from their 2010 effort The Generous Mr. Lovewell, which broke many Christian radio stereotypes and still saw considerable success. Now in 2014, the group has teamed up with the diverse production and composition team of Soli Olds (yes, Mr. Soul Glow Activatur himself, formerly of Family Force 5), Ben Glover and Dave Garcia to break the aforementioned monotony, and the result of that effort is the aptly-titled Welcome To The New.

What MercyMe has offered us on Welcome To The New is a highly eclectic collection of different sounds that altogether make a statement that they had no intention of making an album simply destined as a vehicle for radio hits. Many have already gotten a taste of this statement with their jazzy lead single "Shake." I, for one, was completely taken off guard by this choice for a lead single, and was unsure what to think of it (not to mention I was unimpressed by the lyrics; what exactly does it mean to "shake like you are changed"?). But the jazziness of "Shake" is just one of those seemingly bizarre sounds that the band creates on this record, including bringing in some R&B, gospel, country, folk pop, and (of course) their familiar brand of AC. Arguably, no genre could accurately describe consecutive songs on the tracklist. This makes sense as the album's whole theme revolves around the concept of change and the eclectic mix of styles the album offers speaks volumes to that effect as well. Change is also the most powerful lyrical theme as well, with every song, from the opening title track ("It's like you're seeing grace / In a brand new light / For the first time") to the finishing "Dear Younger Me" ("Dear younger me do I go deep / And try to change / The choices that you'll make 'cause they're choices that made me"), talking about change and being made new in some capacity. This album is lyrically MercyMe's most cohesive and impressive effort in some time.

Unfortunately, this album's greatest opponent could end up being itself. There is a fine line between making an artistic statement, and simply being chaotic and unorganized, and with the seemingly wild jumping from style to style between songs, Welcome To The New flirts with it. Not to mention, there is an inherent risk whenever a band undergoes a significant stylistic shift and it's that it merely changes for the sake of change, and the final result is simply an inferior version of the genre (or genres) they are attempting to mimic. Personally, I have mixed towards the final execution of MercyMe's stylistic shift; while it is undoubtedly a new creative direction for the band that fulfills their mission of breaking the monotony inherent in their fan base, these songs serve as mere appetizers for the genres they are propagating, and may not hold up well under the more scrutinizing ears of outsiders and fans of these aforementioned genres.

The first several listens to the album left me impressed, but subsequent listens seemed to make the flaws speak louder and louder. In all likelihood, the amount of scrutiny one gives to the appetizer-sized execution of the diverse musical styles offered within will likely correlate strongly to how much one enjoys this album, either serving as its biggest strength or its downfall in the listener's eyes. But one can only admire the amount of flair offered by the veteran band on their 8th album in throwing expectations out the door and giving something new to their usual audience. Without a doubt, Welcome To The New is worth a try for any fan of Christian music, and while many will be put off by it, many more will love it.

- Review date: 4/6/14, written by Mark Rice of

Get the new book by Tanner Olson!


. Record Label: Fair Trade Services
. Album length: 10 tracks: 40 minutes, 48 seconds
. Street Date: April 8, 2014
. Buy It: iTunes
. Buy It:

  1. Welcome To the New (3:19)
  2. Gotta Let It Go (2:58)
  3. Shake (3:13)
  4. Greater (4:07)
  5. Finish What He Started (4:28)
  6. Flawless (4:15)
  7. New Lease On Life (3:02)
  8. Wishful Thinking (4:52)
  9. Burn Baby Burn (3:51)
  10. Dear Younger Me (3:26)
  11. Shake [Video] (3:16) (*Digital Versions*)
spacer Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics
Click For Audio Sample   Click For Song Lyrics


Leave a Comment



go to main Album review page
go to Album review archive


(JFH Sponsor Spot)



Get the new book by Tanner Olson!

Search JFH

This Friday, September 18, 2020
7eventh Time Down Questions - Single [BEC]
A Jesus Church Take Your Throne [BEC Worship]
Austin & Lindsey Adamec Can't Deny It - Single [Integrity]
Apollo LTD Better - Single [Centricity]
Cross Point Music Never Stop Singing - Single [Centricity]
Disciple Love Letter Kill Shot (Deluxe) [Tooth & Nail]
Fit for a King The Path [Solid State]
Austin French Wake Up Sleeper EP [Fair Trade]
Jordan Feliz Wounds - Single [Centricity]
Jason Gray Right On Time - Single [Centricity]
Koryn Hawthorne I AM [Provident]
Hulvey Otherside - Single [Reach]
Kari Jobe First Love (Live) EP [Capitol CMG]
Tasha Layton Into the Sea EP [BEC]
Ashlyn Levoy Something Better - Single [Centricity]
Local Sound Won't Let Go - Single [Running Club/Integrity]
Dr. James Mable Jr. The Journey 2.0 [eOne]
Evvie McKinney Look No Further - Single [Motown Gospel]
Chris Renzema Mercy - Single [Centricity]
REVERE REVERE (Live) [Integrity]
Seventh Day Slumber Unseen: The Lamb - EP [RockFest]
SongLab My Favorite (Live From South Eden) - Single [DREAM]

Next Friday, September 25, 2020
Landry Cantrell Glasshouse [DREAM]
Natalie Grant No Stranger [Curb/Word]
Coby James Infinite - Single [Centricity]
Bryon Juane Promise I'm Not Crazy EP [RMG]
KB His Glory Alone [HGA/Essential Sound]
Tasha Cobbs Leonard Royalty: Live At The Ryman [Motown Gospel]
Jessy Elsa Palma Jehovah - Single [Integrity]
Mr. Talkbox Playlist (independent)
PEABOD Wonderful & Scary - Single [Centricity]
Sarah Reeves Motions - Single [Curb/Word]
Slick Shoes Rotation & Frequency [Tooth & Nail]
WHATUPRG New Hollywood [Reach]

For all release dates, click here!

Listen to the new children's album from The Block Worship!

Listen to the new album from Radio Friendly!