Two highly-trained operatives become close after being sent to protect opposite sides of a mysterious gorge. When an evil emerges, they must work together to survive what lies within. (from IMDb)

Scott Derrickson's The Gorge starts off incredibly strong, blending romance, action, and sci-fi into something that feels genuinely fresh. The setup is fantastic; Miles Teller and Anya Taylor-Joy turn in stellar performances, their chemistry making the film's unconventional "long-distance" relationship dynamic both amusing and endearing. The humor lands well, the action sequences are tight, and the world-building is (initially) just vague enough to keep things intriguing. (By the close of the first half, I was convinced this was going to be one of my favorite films of the year.)

Then, the film starts explaining itself.

The best mysteries work because they leave room for the audience to chew on the unknown, and The Gorge overplays its hand. The reveal of a generic "greedy private military corporation doing unethical experiments" is painfully uninspired, dragging the story into predictable Jason Bourne-lite territory. It's the kind of "twist" that would have felt more at home in a lesser sci-fi thriller, not in a film that had been so meticulously building something unique. The problem isn't that The Gorge eventually takes us into the Gorge itself -- that much was inevitable. The issue is how much time it spends there and how drastically the film shifts gears (and staggers along the way), eroding both atmosphere and believability. What began as a weirdly sweet, high-concept romance with strong genre-blending ends up bloating into an extended action-heavy slog that undercuts its own mystique.

Sigourney Weaver is more than fine, but her character lands in an awkward in-between space, underdeveloped yet given just enough presence to feel like a tacked-on afterthought. And while the film does eventually find its way back to its romantic core, the emotional payoff isn't as potent as it should be. The audience needed to be more invested in their story, and the final scene just needed stronger writing. It should have been more gripping and intimate, not buried beneath so much unnecessary spectacle.

That said, The Gorge is still a really good film. The cinematography is strong, the sound design and licensed track selections are excellent (including a fantastic instrumental nod to "All Along the Watchtower"), and the first half alone makes it worth watching. If Derrickson (one of my favorite directors) had kept his cards closer to his chest and trusted the story's more intimate strengths, this movie could have been something truly legendary. As it stands, however, it's an ambitious, well-acted, and mostly entertaining film -- just one that doesn't quite stick the landing.

- David Craft (reviewed: 3/13/25)